Echo Chambers in the Age of Algorithms: An Audit of Twitter's Friend Recommender System

Kayla Duskin,Joseph S. Schafer,Jevin D. West,Emma S. Spiro

2024-04-10

Abstract:The presence of political misinformation and ideological echo chambers on social media platforms is concerning given the important role that these sites play in the public's exposure to news and current events. Algorithmic systems employed on these platforms are presumed to play a role in these phenomena, but little is known about their mechanisms and effects. In this work, we conduct an algorithmic audit of Twitter's Who-To-Follow friend recommendation system, the first empirical audit that investigates the impact of this algorithm in-situ. We create automated Twitter accounts that initially follow left and right affiliated U.S. politicians during the 2022 U.S. midterm elections and then grow their information networks using the platform's recommender system. We pair the experiment with an observational study of Twitter users who already follow the same politicians. Broadly, we find that while following the recommendation algorithm leads accounts into dense and reciprocal neighborhoods that structurally resemble echo chambers, the recommender also results in less political homogeneity of a user's network compared to accounts growing their networks through social endorsement. Furthermore, accounts that exclusively followed users recommended by the algorithm had fewer opportunities to encounter content centered on false or misleading election narratives compared to choosing friends based on social endorsement.

Social and Information Networks,Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to explore and address how algorithmic recommendation systems on social media platforms (specifically Twitter) affect users' information environments and personal network structures. Specifically, the study focuses on whether and how Twitter's "follow recommendation" algorithm promotes the formation of political echo chambers and examines the impact of this algorithm on users' exposure to false or misleading information.

Researchers conducted an algorithm audit experiment by creating automated Twitter accounts during the 2022 U.S. midterm elections. These accounts initially followed political candidates from different parties (Democratic and Republican) and used the platform's recommendation system to expand their social networks. The main contributions of the study include:

1. **Design and Implementation**: Describes the first algorithm audit design and implementation targeting Twitter's "follow recommendation" algorithm, simulating the process of users building social networks through automated accounts.
2. **Data Collection and Analysis**: Collected and analyzed a unique longitudinal dataset that recorded the social networks of each account over time and the content they might be exposed to, including observational data similar to real Twitter users.
3. **Empirical Findings**: Results show that networks formed by Twitter's "follow recommendation" algorithm are less polarized than those formed based on social endorsement strategies. This finding is significant for understanding the role of social algorithms in political polarization and their potential mitigating effects.

In summary, the paper aims to fill the empirical research gap on the impact of Twitter's "follow recommendation" algorithm on echo chamber effects and the spread of false information.