Abstract:In the resource-constrained world of the digital landscape, lightweight cryptography plays a critical role in safeguarding information and ensuring the security of various systems, devices, and communication channels. Its efficient and resource-friendly nature makes it the ideal solution for applications where computational power is limited. In response to the growing need for platform-specific implementations, NIST issued a call for standardization of Lightweight cryptography algorithms in 2018. Ascon emerged as the winner of this competition. NIST initially established general evaluation criteria for a standard lightweight scheme including security strength, mitigation against side-channel and fault-injection attacks, and implementation efficiency. To verify the security claims, evaluating the individual components used in any cryptographic algorithm is a crucial step. The quality of a substitution box (S-box) significantly impacts the overall security of a cryptographic primitive. This paper analyzes the S-boxes of six finalists in the NIST Lightweight Cryptography (LWC) standardization process. We evaluate them based on well-established cryptographic properties. Our analysis explores how these properties influence the S-boxes' resistance against known cryptanalytic attacks and potential implementation-specific vulnerabilities, thus reflecting on their compliance with NIST's security requirements.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate and analyze the security of S - boxes (Substitution box, abbreviated as S - box) in six final candidate algorithms participating in the NIST lightweight cryptography standard competition. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points: 1. **Evaluating the cryptographic properties of S - boxes**: Evaluate these S - boxes through a series of established cryptographic properties to ensure that they meet NIST's security requirements. 2. **The ability to resist known attacks**: Study the performance of these S - boxes when facing known cryptanalysis attacks (such as differential cryptanalysis, linear cryptanalysis, etc.). 3. **The impact of implementing specific vulnerabilities**: Explore the implementation - specific vulnerabilities that may exist in these S - boxes in practical applications and evaluate their potential impact on overall security. ### Detailed Interpretation #### Background and Motivation With the rapid development of Internet of Things (IoT) devices and other resource - constrained environments, lightweight cryptography has become extremely important. This type of cryptography aims to provide efficient and secure information protection for devices with limited computing power. In 2018, NIST (National Institute of Standards and Technology, USA) launched a call for lightweight cryptography standards to meet this need. After multiple rounds of evaluation, several candidate algorithms were finally selected, including Ascon, which eventually became the winner of the NIST lightweight cryptography standard. #### Research Objectives The main objective of this paper is to conduct an in - depth security analysis of S - boxes in these six final candidate algorithms of the NIST lightweight cryptography standard competition. The S - box is a key component to ensure the confusion characteristics of cryptographic primitives, and its quality directly affects the security of the entire cryptographic system. #### Main Contributions - **Comprehensive property evaluation**: The paper conducts a detailed evaluation of S - boxes based on a variety of cryptographic properties, including but not limited to nonlinearity, Differential Distribution Table (DDT), Linear Approximation Table (LAT), etc. - **Attack vector analysis**: Explore the vulnerabilities of these S - boxes when facing different types of cryptanalysis attacks, especially those attacks that utilize specific properties of S - boxes. - **Implementation security**: Analyze the implementation - specific vulnerabilities that may exist in S - boxes in practical application scenarios and how these vulnerabilities affect overall security. #### Methodology To achieve the above objectives, the authors adopted the following methods: - **Property classification**: Classify S - box properties according to relevant cryptanalysis techniques, such as linear cryptanalysis, differential cryptanalysis, etc. - **Theoretical boundary analysis**: Determine the theoretical upper and lower limits of various properties and discuss the behavior of these properties under affine equivalence transformation. - **Experimental verification**: Verify their security and anti - attack ability through detailed experimental analysis of S - boxes in six candidate algorithms. ### Conclusion Through systematic evaluation and analysis, this paper fills the gap in the existing literature regarding the cryptographic properties of S - boxes in NIST lightweight cryptography standard candidate algorithms, providing an important reference for designing more secure lightweight cryptographic systems. --- Hope this summary can help you understand the core problem of this paper and its solution methods. If you have any further questions or need more detailed information, please feel free to let us know.

S-box Security Analysis of NIST Lightweight Cryptography Candidates: A Critical Empirical Study

An analytical review of current S-box design methodologies, performance evaluation criteria, and major challenges

Review of the NIST Light-weight Cryptography Finalists

Symmetry Analysis in Construction Two Dynamic Lightweight S-Boxes Based on the 2D Tinkerbell Map and the 2D Duffing Map

A Comprehensive Survey on the Implementations, Attacks, and Countermeasures of the Current NIST Lightweight Cryptography Standard

S-box design based on optimize LFT parameter selection: a practical approach in recommendation system domain

Construction of Robust Lightweight S-Boxes Using Enhanced Logistic and Enhanced Sine Maps

A Novel Secure S-box Design Methodology Based on FPGA and SHA-256 Hash Algorithm for Block Cipher Algorithms

Trade-Offs for S-Boxes: Cryptographic Properties and Side-Channel Resilience

The reality of backdoored S-Boxes—An eye opener

Semi-Permanent Stuck-At Fault injection attacks on Elephant and GIFT lightweight ciphers

Innovative Transformation of S-Box Through Chaotic Map Using a Pragmatic Approach

Chaos and Cellular Automata-Based Substitution Box and Its Application in Cryptography

Dynamic S-Box Construction Using Mordell Elliptic Curves over Galois Field and Its Applications in Image Encryption

A Novel Scheme for Construction of S-Box Using Action of Power Associative Loop and Its Applications in Text Encryption

Group-Action-Based S-box Generation Technique for Enhanced Block Cipher Security and Robust Image Encryption Scheme

A novel systematic byte substitution method to design strong bijective substitution box (S-box) using piece-wise-linear chaotic map

Block Cipher's Substitution Box Generation Based on Natural Randomness in Underwater Acoustics and Knight's Tour Chain

S-box design based on logistic skewed chaotic map and modified Rabin-Karp algorithm: applications to multimedia security

A new analysis of small S-boxes based on a new notion of algebraic immunity

Block Ciphers Substitution Box Generation Based on Natural Randomness in Underwater Acoustics and Knights Tour Chain