Comment to the paper J. Yan et al. Experimental confirmation of driving pressure boosting and smoothing for hybrid-drive inertial fusion at the 100-kJ laser facility [Nature Communications (2023) 14:5782]

Ke Lan
2024-07-23
Abstract:The lack of experimental data on the direct-drive pressure leads us to the conclusion that, the published experimental confirmation of driving pressure boosting and smoothing for hybrid-drive inertial fusion is not credible.
Plasma Physics,High Energy Physics - Experiment
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to question the experimental confirmation of the driving pressure enhancement and smoothing effect in Hybrid - Drive Inertial Fusion (HD). Specifically, the author of the paper points out: 1. **Lack of key data**: The original paper lacks the pressure data of the Direct - Drive (DD) laser under the same conditions, as well as the observed asymmetry data. The lack of these data makes the conclusions of the original paper lack sufficient support. 2. **Loose logic**: Due to the lack of the above - mentioned data, the logical chain in the original paper is incomplete, so its conclusions are unreliable. ### Specific problem points - **Pressure comparison**: The original paper reports that in a 100 kJ laser facility using hemispherical and planar targets, the driving pressure is enhanced and smoothed through the combined action of Indirect - Drive (ID) and Direct - Drive lasers. However, the reviewer points out that the pressure data of the Direct - Drive laser acting alone is not provided, which makes it impossible to clarify the specific contribution of the Direct - Drive laser in pressure enhancement. - **Pressure smoothing**: The original paper claims that the hybrid - drive scheme can provide a smoother pressure distribution than the radiative ablation pressure, but no experimental evidence is provided to support this. The reviewer believes that the Direct - Drive laser itself will also produce significant asymmetry, which is ignored in the original paper. - **Advantage verification**: In order to verify the advantages of the hybrid - drive scheme in terms of pressure enhancement and smoothing, it is necessary to measure the pressure in three cases: Indirect - Drive only, Direct - Drive only, and hybrid - drive. Since the original paper does not provide these data, it is impossible to prove the actual advantages of the hybrid - drive scheme. ### Conclusion The reviewer believes that due to the lack of key data and loose logic, the experimental confirmation of the driving pressure enhancement and smoothing effect in the original paper on hybrid - drive inertial fusion is not credible. In order to make the conclusions more reliable, further experimental data are needed to support the advantages of the hybrid - drive scheme.