Hydrodynamical simulations favor a pure deflagration origin of the near-Chandrasekhar mass supernova remnant 3C 397

Vrutant Mehta,Jack Sullivan,Robert Fisher,Yuken Ohshiro,Hiroya Yamaguchi,Khanak Bhargava,Sudarshan Neopane

2024-04-06

Abstract:Suzaku X-ray observations of the Type Ia supernova remnant (SNR) 3C 397 discovered exceptionally high mass ratios of Mn/Fe, Ni/Fe, and Cr/Fe, consistent with a near $M_{\rm Ch}$ progenitor white dwarf (WD). The Suzaku observations have established 3C 397 as our best candidate for a near-$M_{\rm Ch}$ SNR Ia, and opened the way to address additional outstanding questions about the origin and explosion mechanism of these transients. In particular, subsequent XMM-Newton observations revealed an unusually clumpy distribution of iron group elemental (IGE) abundances within the ejecta of 3C 397. In this paper, we undertake a suite of two dimensional hydrodynamical models, varying both the explosion mechanism -- either deflagration-to-detonation (DDT), or pure deflagration -- WD progenitors, and WD progenitor metallicity, and analyze their detailed nucleosynthetic abundances and associated clumping. We find that pure deflagrations naturally give rise to clumpy distributions of neutronized species concentrated towards the outer limb of the remnant, and confirm DDTs have smoothly structured ejecta with a central concentration of neutronization. Our findings indicate that 3C 397 was most likely a pure deflagration of a high central density WD. We discuss a range of implications of these findings for the broader SN Ia progenitor problem.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,Solar and Stellar Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to determine the explosion mechanism of the near - Chandrasekhar - mass supernova remnant 3C 397 and the properties of its progenitor star. Specifically, through two - dimensional hydrodynamic simulations, the researchers explored the influence of two different explosion mechanisms - pure deflagration (pure defect) and deflagration - to - detonation transition (DDT), as well as white dwarf progenitor stars with different central densities, on the highly inhomogeneous iron - group element (IGE) abundance distribution observed in 3C 397. The main objectives of the paper include:

1. **Determine the explosion mechanism of 3C 397**: The researchers hope to determine, through simulation results, whether 3C 397 was produced by pure deflagration or deflagration - to - detonation transition. These two mechanisms show significant differences in the distribution of explosion products, especially for the distribution of neutron - rich elements.

2. **Explain the high abundance ratios observed in 3C 397**: Through simulations, the researchers hope to explain why abnormally high Mn/Fe, Ni/Fe and Cr/Fe abundance ratios were observed in 3C 397. These high abundance ratios suggest that 3C 397 may come from a white dwarf progenitor star close to the Chandrasekhar limit mass.

3. **Understand the influence of the explosion mechanism on ejecta mixing**: The researchers also hope to explore, through simulation results, how different explosion mechanisms affect the mixing state of ejecta, especially the spatial distribution of iron - group elements found in XMM - Newton observations.

4. **Explore the broader issue of type Ia supernova progenitor stars**: Through the study of 3C 397, the researchers hope to provide new insights into the broader issue of type Ia supernova progenitor stars, especially regarding how these supernovae are formed and under what conditions deflagration - to - detonation transition occurs.

### Simulation methods

The researchers used the FLASH 4 hydrodynamic code for simulations. This code supports adaptive mesh refinement (AMR) and can achieve high resolution in areas of interest. The simulations considered two main explosion mechanisms:

- **Deflagration - to - detonation transition (DDT)**: In this mechanism, flame bubbles initiate combustion inside the white dwarf and, as they rise due to buoyancy, eventually transition to detonation.
- **Pure deflagration (pure defect)**: In this mechanism, flame bubbles are ignited near the center of the white dwarf, and the combustion passes through the dense core but does not transition to detonation.

The researchers also considered white dwarf progenitor stars with different central densities, namely models with high central density (\( \rho_c = 6.0\times 10^9 \) g/cm³) and standard central density (\( \rho_c = 2.2\times 10^9 \) g/cm³).

### Main results

1. **DDT model**: The DDT model shows that the combustion products present a smoothly stratified structure, and the neutron - rich elements are concentrated in the central region, which is inconsistent with the inhomogeneous distribution observed in 3C 397.

2. **Pure deflagration model**: The pure deflagration model shows that the distribution of neutron - rich elements is highly inhomogeneous, forming multiple clumps, which is more consistent with the situation observed in 3C 397.

3. **Ejecta mass and velocity**: The ejecta mass of the pure deflagration model is smaller and the velocity is lower, while the ejecta mass of the DDT model is larger and the velocity is higher.

### Conclusion

The researchers' simulation results indicate that 3C 397 is most likely a pure deflagration event of a white dwarf with high central density. This conclusion not only explains the high abundance ratios observed in 3C 397, but also provides a new perspective for understanding the issue of type Ia supernova progenitor stars.