The economic consequences of geopolitical fragmentation: Evidence from the Cold War

Rodolfo G. Campos,Benedikt Heid,Jacopo Timini

2024-04-04

Abstract:The Cold War was the defining episode of geopolitical fragmentation in the twentieth century. Trade between East and West across the Iron Curtain (a symbolical and physical barrier dividing Europe into two distinct areas) was restricted, but the severity of these restrictions varied over time. We quantify the trade and welfare effects of the Iron Curtain and show how the difficulty of trading across the Iron Curtain fluctuated throughout the Cold War. Using a novel dataset on trade between the two economic blocs and a quantitative trade model, we find that while the Iron Curtain at its height represented a tariff equivalent of 48% in 1951, trade between East and West gradually became easier until the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989. Despite the easing of trade restrictions, we estimate that the Iron Curtain roughly halved East-West trade flows and caused substantial welfare losses in the Eastern bloc countries that persisted until the end of the Cold War. Conversely, the Iron Curtain led to an increase in intra-bloc trade, especially in the Eastern bloc, which outpaced the integration of Western Europe in the run-up to the formation of the European Union.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the impact of the Iron Curtain on East-West trade and welfare during the Cold War. Specifically, the study aims to quantify the effect of the Iron Curtain as a political, military, and cultural barrier on trade flows between the East and the West, and to analyze how this impact changed over time.

The authors utilized a new trade dataset and a quantitative trade model to assess the trade costs imposed by the Iron Curtain during different historical periods. They found that during the peak restriction period of the Iron Curtain in 1951, its impact on trade was equivalent to a 48% tariff. Over time, although trade restrictions between the East and the West were somewhat relaxed, the Iron Curtain still resulted in approximately halving the trade flow between the East and the West and caused significant welfare losses for the Eastern Bloc countries, which persisted until the end of the Cold War.

Furthermore, the paper points out that while the Iron Curtain increased trade barriers between the East and the West, it also promoted trade integration within the East and the West. Particularly within the Eastern Bloc, the degree of trade integration even surpassed the level of Western European countries before the formation of the European Union.

In summary, through detailed quantitative analysis, the paper reveals the specific impact of the Iron Curtain on international trade and economic welfare during the Cold War. It provides important insights into how historical trade barriers have changed, which is valuable for understanding the potential economic consequences of current and future geopolitical divisions.