Abstract:Molecules under strong or ultra-strong light-matter coupling present an intriguing route to modify chemical structure, properties, and reactivity. A rigorous theoretical treatment of such systems requires handling matter and photon degrees of freedom on an equal quantum mechanical footing. In the regime of molecular electronic strong or ultra-strong coupling to one or a few molecules, it is desirable to treat the molecular electronic degrees of freedom using the tools of ab initio quantum chemistry, yielding an approach referred to as ab initio cavity quantum electrodynamics (ai-QED), where the photon degrees of freedom are treated at the level of cavity quantum electrodynamics. In this letter, we analyze two complementary approaches to ai-QED: (1) parameterized CQED (pQED), a two-step approach where the matter degrees of freedom are computed using existing electronic structure theories, enabling the construction of rigorous ai-QED Hamiltonians in a basis of many-electron eigenstates, and (2) self-consistent CQED (scQED), a one-step approach where electronic structure methods are generalized to include coupling between electronic and photon degrees of freedom. Although these approaches are equivalent in their exact limits, we identify a disparity between the projection of the two-body dipole self-energy operator that appears in the pQED approach and its exact counterpart in the scQED approach. We provide a theoretical argument that this disparity resolves only under the limit of a complete orbital basis and a complete many-electron basis for the projection. We present numerical results highlighting this disparity and its resolution in simple molecular systems, where it is possible to approach these two complete basis limits simultaneously. Additionally, we examine and compare the practical issue of computational cost required to converge each approach towards the complete orbital and many-electron bases.

Electron-Phonon Coupling using Many-Body Perturbation Theory: Implementation in the Questaal Electronic Structure Suite

Electron-phonon coupling from GW perturbation theory: Practical workflow combining BerkeleyGW, ABINIT, and EPW

The Electron-Phonon Renormalization in the Electronic Structure Calculation: Fundamentals, Current Status, and Challenges

Accurate Electron-phonon Interactions from Advanced Density Functional Theory

Phonons from Density-Functional Perturbation Theory using the All-Electron Full-Potential Linearized Augmented Plane-Wave Method FLEUR

Capturing electronic correlations in electron-phonon interactions in molecular systems with the GW approximation

Ab Initio Electron-Phonon Interactions in Correlated Electron Systems

Questaal: a package of electronic structure methods based on the linear muffin-tin orbital technique

A Hybrid Quantum-Classical Method for Electron-Phonon Systems

Long-range quadrupole electron-phonon interaction from first principles

Accelerating the calculation of electron-phonon coupling strength with machine learning

Non-perturbative theory of the electron-phonon coupling and its first-principles implementation

Structure and dynamics of electron-phonon coupled systems using neural quantum states

A coupled cluster framework for electrons and phonons

EPIq : an open-source software for the calculation of electron-phonon interaction related properties

Combining density functional theory with macroscopic QED for quantum light-matter interactions in 2D materials

Comparing parameterized and self-consistent approaches to ab inito CQED for electronic strong coupling

EPW: A program for calculating the electron-phonon coupling using maximally localized Wannier functions

First-principles molecular quantum electrodynamics theory at all coupling strengths

In- and out-of-equilibrium {\em ab initio} theory of electrons and phonons

Quantum Electrodynamics Coupled-Cluster Theory: Exploring Photon-Induced Electron Correlations