Nestings of BIBDs with block size four

Marco Buratti,Donald L. Kreher,Douglas R. Stinson
2024-04-03
Abstract:In a nesting of a balanced incomplete block design (or BIBD), we wish to add a point (the \emph{nested point}) to every block of a $(v,k,\lambda)$-BIBD in such a way that we end up with a partial $(v,k+1,\lambda+1)$-BIBD. In the case where the partial $(v,k+1,\lambda+1)$-BIBD is in fact a $(v,k+1,\lambda+1)$-BIBD, we have a \emph{perfect nesting}. We show that a nesting is perfect if and only if $k = 2 \lambda + 1$.
Combinatorics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the existence and construction of nested balanced incomplete block designs (BIBD), especially for BIBD with block size 4 (i.e., $(v,4,1)$ - BIBD). Specifically, the researchers hope to find a method to add a point to each block in a given $(v,4,1)$ - BIBD so that the result forms a partial $(v,5,2)$ - BIBD. If this partial design is actually a complete $(v,5,2)$ - BIBD, it is called perfect nesting. The main contribution of the paper lies in completely determining the pedigree of nested $(v,4,1)$ - BIBD and proving that such a nested design exists if and only if $v \equiv 1 \text{ or } 4 \pmod{12}$ and $v \geq 13$. In addition, the researchers also provide a variety of direct and recursive construction methods to generate these nested designs, including using difference techniques, computer algorithms and other tools in combinatorial design theory. To achieve this goal, the authors first introduce the concept of related nested group divisible designs (GDD) and prove some necessary conditions. For example, for a $(k,\lambda)$ - GDD, if it can be perfectly nested, it must satisfy $k = 2\lambda + 1$. Then, they show by specific examples how to use relative difference families (RDF) and Banff relative difference families (BRDF) to construct nested $(v,4,1)$ - BIBD. Finally, the authors also explore the connections between nested $(v,4,1)$ - BIBD and other mathematical structures, such as Levi graphs of harmonious colorings, etc., and propose possible future research directions.