Physics Faculty and Empathy in Academic Spaces

Rachel Merrill,Alia Hamdan,Ash Bista,Scott Franklin

2024-04-03

Abstract:The ability to emotionally or intellectually understand another person's thoughts and feelings-empathy-can foster critical connections that facilitate learning and collaboration. We present a case study of physics faculty that examines their experiences empathizing with students, both in and outside of the classroom. We expand on frameworks for understanding the empathy process by identifying key mediating factors, and note various barriers that faculty express as preventing them from taking empathetic action. Our analysis unpacks the mechanisms of communication and contextual information, which play key roles in the empathetic process, with implications for programs that rely on empathy to develop more inclusive STEM academic spaces.

Physics Education

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper explores how physics teachers understand and apply empathy in academic environments, as well as the key mediating factors that influence their empathetic actions. The study reveals the importance of communication in the process of empathy and identifies barriers faced by teachers when expressing empathy. The paper suggests that mediating factors, such as dis-communication, exist between teachers' recognition of inequality, empathy towards students, and decision to take action, which may prevent effective empathy from being conveyed. The research also highlights the role of contextual information in triggering cognitive empathy, but the complexity of communication and potential misunderstandings impede the transformation of empathy into actual actions. Additionally, the paper proposes that the development of empathy is not an isolated individual process, but requires communication between both parties. Future research needs to further explore the cyclical relationship between fostering empathy and addressing oppressive behaviors.