Abstract:arising from C. Dailey et al. Nature Astronomy https://doi.org/10.1038/s41550-020-01242-7 (2021) In their study, Dailey et al. 1 claimed that networks of quantum sensors can be used as sensitive multi-messenger probes of astrophysical phenomena that produce intense bursts of relativistic bosonic waves that interact non-gravitationally with ordinary matter. The most promising possibility considered in ref. 1 involved clock-based searches for quadratic scalar-type interactions, with greatly diminished reach in the case of magnetometer-based searches for derivative-pseudoscalar-type interactions and clock-based searches for linear scalar-type interactions. In this Matters Arising, we show that the aforementioned work overlooked the 'back action' of ordinary matter on scalar waves with quadratic interactions, which can greatly affect the detection prospects of clock networks. In particular, back action can cause strong screening of scalar waves near Earth's surface and by the apparatus itself, potentially rendering clock experiments insensitive to extraterrestrial sources of relativistic scalar waves. Back-action effects can also slow the propagation of scalar waves through the interstellar and intergalactic media, which can in turn substantially delay the arrival of scalar waves at Earth, compared with their gravitational-wave counterparts, and prevent multi-messenger astronomy on timescales comparable to the average human life expectancy. Our findings and conclusions apply to quadratic scalar-type interactions with the particular signs chosen in ref. 1 .

Making two particle detectors in flat spacetime communicate quantumly

Relativistic quantum communication between harmonic oscillator detectors

How cosmological expansion affects communication between distant quantum systems

Quantum Communication in Rindler Spacetime

Particle detectors in superposition in de Sitter spacetime

Transmission of quantum information through quantum fields in curved spacetimes

Causality and signalling in non-compact detector-field interactions

Accelerated Particle Detectors with Modified Dispersion Relations

Quantum teleportation between moving detectors in a quantum field

Decoherence and Disentanglement of Qubits Detecting Scalar Fields in an Expanded Spacetime

Accelerated detector in a superposed spacetime

The Unruh-DeWitt model and its joint interacting Hilbert space

Particle-field duality in QFT measurements

Particle Detectors, Cavities, and the Weak Equivalence Principle

Radiative processes of single and entangled detectors on circular trajectories in (2+1) dimensional Minkowski spacetime

Uniformly accelerated quantum counting detector in Minkowski and Fulling vacuum states

Relativistic quantum broadcast channel

Radiative processes of single and entangled detectors on circular trajectories in ( )-dimensional Minkowski spacetime

Highlighting the back-action contribution of matter to quantum sensor network performance in multi-messenger astronomy

Absolutely covert quantum communication

Detection time of Dirac particles in one space dimension