Abstract:The honeycomb Kitaev model describes a $Z_2$ spin liquid with topological order and fractionalized excitations consisting of gapped $\pi$-fluxes and free Majorana fermions. Competing interactions, even when not very strong, are known to destabilize the Kitaev spin liquid. Magnetic fields are a convenient parameter for tuning between different phases of the Kitaev systems, and have even been investigated for potentially counteracting the effects of other destabilizing interactions leading to a revival of the topological phase. Here we review the progress in understanding the effects of magnetic fields on some of the perturbed Kitaev systems, particularly on fractionalization and topological order.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the changes in spin fractionalization and topological order in the Kitaev system under magnetic field tuning and their implications. Specifically, the paper focuses on how the magnetic field affects spin fractionalization and topological order in the Kitaev model, particularly whether the magnetic field can restore or enhance these properties in the presence of competing interactions.
### Main Research Questions:
1. **Impact of Magnetic Field on Spin Fractionalization in the Kitaev System**: Investigate how the magnetic field alters the phenomenon of spin fractionalization in the Kitaev system, especially the changes under low and high field conditions.
2. **Impact of Magnetic Field on Topological Order**: Explore how the magnetic field affects the topological order in the Kitaev system, particularly whether there is an intermediate field phase and the nature of this phase.
3. **Synergistic Effects of Competing Interactions and Magnetic Field**: Study how the combined effects of the magnetic field and other competing interactions (such as Heisenberg exchange, anisotropic interactions, etc.) influence spin fractionalization and topological order in the Kitaev system.
4. **Experimental Verification**: Verify theoretical predictions through experimental means (such as neutron scattering, Raman spectroscopy, thermal conductivity measurements, etc.), particularly the signs of spin fractionalization and topological order observed under magnetic field tuning.
### Research Background:
- **Kitaev Model**: Describes a quantum spin liquid with Z2 topological order and fractionalized excitations, where lattice spins are decomposed into free Majorana fermions and visons carrying π-flux.
- **Role of Magnetic Field**: A small Zeeman field can introduce three-spin interactions, leading to the opening of a gap in the Majorana fermions and making them chiral. At higher magnetic fields, the vison gap may also change, potentially leading to the degradation of topological order.
- **Competing Interactions**: Other types of spin interactions (such as Heisenberg exchange, anisotropic interactions, etc.) can induce vison fluctuations, thereby disrupting topological order.
### Research Significance:
- **Theoretical Understanding**: Deepening the understanding of how magnetic fields and competing interactions affect spin fractionalization and topological order in the Kitaev system helps to refine related theoretical models.
- **Experimental Guidance**: Providing theoretical basis for experimental design, aiding experimental scientists in observing the unique properties of the Kitaev system under specific conditions.
- **Application Prospects**: The topological properties of the Kitaev system have potential applications in fields such as quantum computing, making the study of its stability under different conditions of great importance.
In summary, this paper aims to comprehensively understand the changes in spin fractionalization and topological order in the Kitaev system under magnetic field tuning through theoretical analysis and experimental verification, providing theoretical support for future experiments and applications.