Abstract:A healthy field combines two driving forces, extension of coverage and theoretical reflection – and modal logic is no exception. In this talk, we look at some broader theoretical issues raised by recent developments in dynamic logics of information flow, whose main technical feature is the modal study of definable model change. Our pilot system will be public announcement logic PAL, the base calculus of update with hard information. We identify several general themes behind the particulars of its design. These include model-theoretic issues like the balance of expressive power for the static and dynamic components of the language, and learnability results in the form of preservation theorems. But we also discuss PAL’s calculus of reasoning, via correspondence analysis of its axioms as constraints on update functions in domains of inquiry, showing how this leads to two recent extensions: protocol versions where no reduction to the static base language occurs, and substitution-closed core versions of the system. Both moves exemplify more general operations on modal logics. Next, we consider other dynamic-epistemic logics, and amplify on the above themes, while adding some new ones. First, we discuss event models and product update in DEL, a calculus of model construction that shows analogies with process algebra, but also with the epistemic μ–calculus. Then we turn to dynamic logics for belief change under incoming hard and soft information that upgrade plausibility relations without eliminating worlds. We discuss what logical format best captures the generality needed to avoid a jungle of revision policies. In this setting also, we look at the general phenomenon of defining new static modalities by dynamic considerations. While all this broadens our view of single-step model transformations, another conspicuous dimension in current research is the global temporal horizon of a process of inquiry, a conversation, or a game, adding procedural information to local updates. We discuss representation results linking local dynamic and global temporal logics, while also pointing at specific model-theoretic issues arising with concrete processes involving iterated hard or soft announcements, and their limit behavior. Here we link up with modal fixed-point logics, though the general situation is far from clear. As a very concrete instance of merging local and global perspectives, we discuss some recent links between dynamic epistemic logics and formal learning theory, where modal models acquire a new meaning as priors pre-encoding learning methods.

Base-extension Semantics for S5 Modal Logic

Base-extension Semantics for Modal Logic

Inferentialist Public Announcement Logic: Base-extension Semantics

Positive Logic with Adjoint Modalities: Proof Theory, Semantics and Reasoning about Information

A Proof-theoretic Semantics for Intuitionistic Linear Logic

Proof-theoretic Semantics for Intuitionistic Multiplicative Linear Logic (Extended Abstract)

From Proof-theoretic Validity to Base-extension Semantics for Intuitionistic Propositional Logic

A New Modal Framework for Epistemic Logic

A Model of Reasoning about Knowledge

Foundational Issues in Logical Dynamics.

Base-based Model Checking for Multi-Agent Only Believing (long version)

Non-Normal Modal Description Logics (Extended Version)

Denotational Semantics for Modal Systems S3–S5 Extended by Axioms for Propositional Quantifiers and Identity

Extending and Implementing the Stable Model Semantics

Public Announcements, Private Actions And Common Knowledge In S5 Structures

Axiomatizing modal inclusion logic and its variants

Depth-bounded epistemic logic

Extensions of K5: Proof Theory and Uniform Lyndon Interpolation

Modal weak Kleene logics: axiomatizations and relational semantics

Stalnaker's Epistemic Logic in Isabelle/HOL