Abstract:Abstract The contact structure of a population plays an important role in transmission of infection. Many ‘structured models’ capture aspects of the contact pattern through an underlying network or a mixing matrix. An important observation in unstructured models of a disease that confers immunity is that once a fraction $$1-1/{\mathcal {R}}_0$$ 1 - 1 / R 0 has been infected, the residual susceptible population can no longer sustain an epidemic. A recent observation of some structured models is that this threshold can be crossed with a smaller fraction of infected individuals, because the disease acts like a targeted vaccine, preferentially immunising higher-risk individuals who play a greater role in transmission. Therefore, a limited ‘first wave’ may leave behind a residual population that cannot support a second wave once interventions are lifted. In this paper, we set out to investigate this more systematically. While networks offer a flexible framework to model contact patterns explicitly, they suffer from several shortcomings: (i) high-fidelity network models require a large amount of data which can be difficult to harvest, and (ii) very few, if any, theoretical contact network models offer the flexibility to tune different contact network properties within the same framework. Therefore, we opt to systematically analyse a number of well-known mean-field models. These are computationally efficient and provide good flexibility in varying contact network properties such as heterogeneity in the number contacts, clustering and household structure or differentiating between local and global contacts. In particular, we consider the question of herd immunity under several scenarios. When modelling interventions as changes in transmission rates, we confirm that in networks with significant degree heterogeneity, the first wave of the epidemic confers herd immunity with significantly fewer infections than equivalent models with less or no degree heterogeneity. However, if modelling the intervention as a change in the contact network, then this effect may become much more subtle. Indeed, modifying the structure disproportionately can shield highly connected nodes from becoming infected during the first wave and therefore make the second wave more substantial. We strengthen this finding by using an age-structured compartmental model parameterised with real data and comparing lockdown periods implemented either as a global scaling of the mixing matrix or age-specific structural changes. Overall, we find that results regarding (disease-induced) herd immunity levels are strongly dependent on the model, the duration of the lockdown and how the lockdown is implemented in the model.

Possible counter-intuitive impact of local vaccine mandates for vaccine-preventable infectious diseases

Local risk perception enhances epidemic control

Modeling Epidemics Spreading on Social Contact Networks

Impact of network assortativity on epidemic and vaccination behaviour

Evaluation of vaccination strategies for SIR epidemics on random networks incorporating household structure

Multiple outbreaks in epidemic spreading with local vaccination and limited vaccines

A geometric analysis of the impact of large but finite switching rates on vaccination evolutionary games

The Impact of Contact Structure and Mixing on Control Measures and Disease-Induced Herd Immunity in Epidemic Models: A Mean-Field Model Perspective

Effect of vaccinations and school restrictions on the spread of COVID-19 in different age groups in Germany

The impact of local vaccine coverage and recent incidence on measles transmission in France between 2009 and 2018

Modelling the impact of opinion flexibility on the vaccination choices during epidemics

Role of Vaccination Strategies to Host-Pathogen Dynamics in Social Interactions

The influence of immune individuals in disease spread evaluated by cellular automaton and genetic algorithm

The effects of imitation dynamics on vaccination behaviours in SIR-network model

Optimal vaccination strategies on networks and in metropolitan areas

The Effect of Vaccination on the Competitive Advantage of Two Strains of an Infectious Disease

Quantifying indirect and direct vaccination effects arising in the SIR model

The Effects of Regional Vaccination Heterogeneity on Measles Outbreaks with France as a Case Study

From regional pulse vaccination to global disease eradication: insights from a mathematical model of poliomyelitis

Vaccination strategies in the disease–behavior evolution model