Abstract:The validity of the subjective evaluation of steering feedback in driving simulators is crucial for modern vehicle development. Although there are established objective steering characteristics for the assessment of both stationary and dynamic feedback behaviour, factors such as steering wheel vibrations and vehicle body motion, particularly in high-frequency ranges, present challenges in simulator fidelity. This work investigates the influence of steering wheel vibration and vehicle body motion frequency content on the subjective evaluation of steering feedback during closed-loop driving in a dynamic driving simulator. A controlled subject study with 30 participants consisting of a back-to-back comparison of a reference vehicle with an electrical power steering system and three variants of its virtual representation on a dynamic driving simulator was performed. Subjective evaluation focused on the representation of road feedback in comparison to the reference vehicle. The statistical analysis of subjective results show that there is a significant influence of the frequency content of both steering wheel torque and vehicle motion on the subjective evaluation of steering feedback in a dynamic driving simulator. The results suggest an influence of frequency content on the subjective evaluation quality of steering feedback characteristics that are not associated with the dynamic feedback behaviour in the context of established performance indicators.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is: In dynamic driving simulators, the subjective evaluation of steering feedback is influenced by the vibration of the steering wheel and the frequency components of vehicle motion. Specifically, the study aims to explore how these frequency components affect the driver's subjective perception of steering feedback, especially under closed-loop driving conditions. By comparing the steering feedback in real vehicles and high-fidelity driving simulators, the research hopes to identify factors that go beyond the known objective characteristics, thereby improving the simulation accuracy and the quality of the driver's experience. ### Background and Motivation Modern vehicle development heavily relies on driving simulators, especially in human-centered design processes. Steering feel (particularly steering torque feedback) plays a crucial role in the subjective evaluation of vehicles. As virtual methods are increasingly applied in steering system development, how to transfer steering characteristics from simulators to real vehicles has become an important research topic. Despite significant progress in virtual development in recent years, the development of steering feel still requires iterative optimization through subjective evaluation by system experts in real vehicles. ### Current State of Research Existing research indicates that steering feel is composed of multiple sensory impressions, with the haptic feedback of the steering wheel torque (SWT) and the visual and kinesthetic feedback of the vehicle body being considered decisive factors. Steering wheel torque has a significant impact on the driver's performance in lateral control tasks and can influence the driver's subjective evaluation of overall vehicle dynamics. However, there are also indications in the literature that factors such as the vibration of the steering wheel and vehicle body, as well as acoustic contributions, may have an important impact on subjective ratings, especially in terms of road feedback perception. ### Research Contributions The main contributions of this study are: 1. **Experimental Design**: A controlled back-to-back subject study was conducted, including one lap of driving in a real vehicle followed by three laps in a high-fidelity driving simulator. 2. **Impact of Frequency Components**: Using high-fidelity representation of the reference system's feedback characteristics, the study investigated the impact of SWT frequency components on the subjective evaluation of steering feedback. 3. **Impact of Vehicle Motion Frequency Components**: The study examined the impact of vehicle motion frequency components in dynamic driving simulators on the subjective evaluation of steering feedback. ### Experimental Design The study collected subjective evaluation data from participants by comparing the driving experience in a real vehicle and three different simulator variants. All participants underwent the same test procedure to ensure consistency in experimental conditions. The key to the experimental design was ensuring high fidelity in the simulator's steering feedback and vehicle motion to accurately replicate the driving experience of a real vehicle. ### Conclusion The study results indicate that the frequency components of steering wheel torque and vehicle motion have a significant impact on the subjective evaluation of steering feedback. These findings help identify factors that go beyond the known objective characteristics, thereby improving the simulation accuracy and the quality of the driver's experience.

Steering Feedback in Dynamic Driving Simulators: The Influence of Steering Wheel Vibration and Vehicle Motion Frequency

Research on Force Characteristics of Steering-wheel System in Tracked Vehicle Simulator

Automotive steering system preferences evaluated using a driving simulator

Study on the Stability of the Steering Torque Feedback System Considering the Time Delay and the System Characteristics

Evaluation of steering feel and vehicle handling in the Stuttgart Driving Simulator (Bewertung von Lenkgefühl und Fahrverhalten im Stuttgarter Fahrsimulator)

Correlations Between Subjective and Objective Evaluations of On-Center Steering Feel

A method to find correlations between steering feel and vehicle handling properties using a moving base driving simulator

Subjective Evaluation Method Study on Vehicle Steering Feeling

A Study on Objective Evaluation of Vehicle Steering Comfort Based on Driver's Electromyogram and Movement Trajectory

A Steering Wheel System and Controller for the Driving Simulator

Experimental identification of a linear parametric driver steering control model with torque feedback

Enhancing perception of vehicle motion by objective positioning of the longitudinal axis of rotation in driving simulators

Energy Feedback Regulation of Automotive Driving Simulator Steering Wheel

Simulating Driving Feel For Virtual Driving Simulator Based On Semi-Physical Simulation

Influences of Active Front Wheel Steering on Vehicle Maneuverand Stability Performance

Evaluation of steering wheel vibration in electric vehicles and application to Dynamic Motor Drive

Methods for modeling the steering wheel torque of a steer-by-wire vehicle

High Speed Emulation in a Vehicle-in-the-Loop Driving Simulator

Objectification of steering feel around straight-line driving for vehicle/tyre design

A New Objective Evaluation Method for Vehicle Steering Comfort

Artificial Steering Feel in Steer by Wire systems: A Simulation Based Evaluation of Control Strategies