Reflecting the Male Gaze: Quantifying Female Objectification in 19th and 20th Century Novels

Kexin Luo,Yue Mao,Bei Zhang,Sophie Hao

2024-03-26

Abstract:Inspired by the concept of the male gaze (Mulvey, 1975) in literature and media studies, this paper proposes a framework for analyzing gender bias in terms of female objectification: the extent to which a text portrays female individuals as objects of visual pleasure. Our framework measures female objectification along two axes. First, we compute an agency bias score that indicates whether male entities are more likely to appear in the text as grammatical agents than female entities. Next, by analyzing the word embedding space induced by a text (Caliskan et al., 2017), we compute an appearance bias score that indicates whether female entities are more closely associated with appearance-related words than male entities. Applying our framework to 19th and 20th century novels reveals evidence of female objectification in literature: we find that novels written from a male perspective systematically objectify female characters, while novels written from a female perspective do not exhibit statistically significant objectification of any gender.

Computation and Language

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to develop a quantitative framework to study the phenomenon of female objectification in literary works and to validate the effectiveness of this framework by analyzing novels from the 19th and 20th centuries.

Specifically, the objectives of the paper include:
1. **Defining Quantitative Metrics**: The author proposes two quantitative metrics to measure the degree of female objectification in texts—Agency Bias and Appearance Bias.
- **Agency Bias**: Measures whether the probability of male entities appearing as grammatical subjects (i.e., action initiators) is higher than that of female entities.
- **Appearance Bias**: Measures whether female entities in the text are more closely associated with appearance-related vocabulary.
2. **Constructing an Analytical Framework**: The author establishes an analytical framework that incorporates natural language processing tools to measure the aforementioned biases.
3. **Empirical Study**: The author uses this framework to conduct an empirical study on 19th and 20th-century English novels to verify the existence of systematic female objectification in these novels.

Findings of the study:
- Overall, these novels show statistically significant evidence of female objectification.
- When controlling for the gender of the author and the narrator, novels written by female authors or using first-person female narrators do not exhibit statistically significant female objectification.
- In contrast, novels written by male authors or using first-person male narrators consistently exhibit both agency bias and appearance bias.

In summary, this paper attempts to reveal gender bias in literary works by developing new quantitative methods and demonstrates the existence of such bias and its association with the gender of the author and the narrator through empirical research.