Development of a Chinese Human-Automation Trust Scale

Zixin Cui,Xiangling Zhuang,Seul Chan Lee,Jieun Lee,Xintong Li,Makoto Itoh
2024-03-25
Abstract:The development of a reliable and valid assessment tool of human-automation trust is an important topic. This study aimed to develop a Chinese version of human-automation trust scale (C-HATS) with reasonable reliability and validity based on Lee and See (2004)'s trust model. After three phases of assessments including exploratory factor analysis, item analysis, and confirmatory factor analysis, different dimensions and items were considered for initial and posttask human-automation trust. For post-task trust, the scale had three dimensions and 11 items and reflected Lee and See (2004)'s model, whereas different from Lee and See (2004)'s model, the final scale had 14 items but only two dimensions for initial trust. Nevertheless, for both initial and post-task trust, reasonable reliability and validity of the scale were verified with various consumer automation products. Although further verification is still necessary, the developed C-HATS could be used to effectively assess human-automation trust in the Chinese context.
Computer Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper focuses on developing a Human-Automation Trust Scale (C-HATS) suitable for the Chinese context. Based on Lee and See's (2004) trust model, the researchers aim to create a reliable and effective assessment tool for measuring individuals' trust in automation systems at different stages, both initially and after task execution. Through exploratory factor analysis, item analysis, and confirmatory factor analysis in three evaluation stages, the researchers identified three dimensions and eleven items related to trust after task execution, as well as two dimensions and fourteen items related to initial trust. Although these dimensions differ from Lee and See's model, the study results demonstrate that C-HATS has reasonable reliability and validity across various consumer automation products. The paper emphasizes the crucial role of human-automation trust in domains such as driving, aviation, and healthcare, while highlighting the risks of overtrust leading to misuse and safety issues. Given the limitations of existing assessment tools, a theory-based and reliable scale is needed to accurately evaluate human-automation trust, particularly in the context of Chinese culture. The research findings suggest that there may be different structural dimensions for initial trust and trust after task execution, deviating from Lee and See's model. Additionally, considering the dynamic nature of human-automation trust and cross-cultural differences, the researchers hope that C-HATS can provide effective assessments for various automation products and different stages of trust development. In summary, this paper aims to address how to develop a reliable and effective theory-based Human-Automation Trust Scale for the Chinese environment, catering to the evaluation needs of different automation systems and stages of trust development.