Abstract:This article shows how coworker performance affects individual performance evaluation in a teamwork setting at the workplace. We use high-quality data on football matches to measure an important component of individual performance, shooting performance, isolated from collaborative effects. Employing causal machine learning methods, we address the assortative matching of workers and estimate both average and heterogeneous effects. There is substantial evidence for spillover effects in performance evaluations. Coworker shooting performance, meaningfully impacts both, manager decisions and third-party expert evaluations of individual performance. Our results underscore the significant role coworkers play in shaping career advancements and highlight a complementary channel, to productivity gains and learning effects, how coworkers impact career advancement. We characterize the groups of workers that are most and least affected by spillover effects and show that spillover effects are reference point dependent. While positive deviations from a reference point create positive spillover effects, negative deviations are not harmful for coworkers.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address the issue of how colleagues' performance affects individual performance evaluations in a team-based work environment. Specifically, the authors investigate whether and how colleagues' performance influences managers' subjective evaluations of individual employee performance in team settings. Additionally, they explore whether this influence varies among different types of employees and work environments.
### Main Research Questions:
1. **Impact of Colleagues' Performance on Individual Performance Evaluations**: The paper aims to reveal how colleagues' performance (e.g., shooting performance) affects individual performance evaluations, including managers' decisions and third-party experts' assessments.
2. **Existence of Spillover Effects**: The study examines the extent to which colleagues' performance impacts individual performance evaluations and whether these effects are asymmetric (i.e., whether positive and negative performances have different impacts).
3. **Differences Among Employee Groups**: The analysis identifies which types of employees are most affected by colleagues' performance and which types are less affected.
4. **Long-term Impact**: The study explores the long-term impact of colleagues' performance on individual career trajectories, including changes in player evaluations over the next 2 years.
### Research Background:
- **Importance of Teamwork**: Modern organizations increasingly adopt teamwork to enhance productivity and foster innovation.
- **Challenges of Performance Evaluation**: Despite the growing prevalence of teamwork, performance evaluations are typically based on individuals, making it difficult to accurately assess individual contributions within a team.
- **Reliance on Subjective Evaluations**: In team tasks, due to the difficulty in distinguishing individual contributions, employers often rely on subjective evaluations to assess employee performance.
### Research Methods:
- **Data Source**: The authors used detailed match data from the Bundesliga, particularly shooting performance measured through advanced player tracking technology.
- **Causal Machine Learning**: Causal machine learning methods were employed to address the non-randomness of colleague matching and to estimate average and heterogeneous effects.
- **Control Variables**: Detailed controls for player quality, match environment, and overall team level were included to reduce selection bias.
### Research Findings:
- **Significant Spillover Effects**: Colleagues' performance significantly influences managers' decisions and third-party experts' evaluations.
- **Asymmetric Effects**: Positive performance has a beneficial impact on colleagues, while negative performance does not have a significant negative impact.
- **Affected Employee Groups**: New hires and lower-skilled employees are more susceptible to the influence of colleagues' performance, whereas high-skilled and experienced employees are less affected.
- **Long-term Impact**: Colleagues' performance has a long-term impact on individual career trajectories, including changes in player evaluations over the next 2 years.
### Research Significance:
- **Supplementary Mechanism**: The study reveals a supplementary mechanism through which colleagues' performance affects career development via performance evaluations.
- **Management Practice**: It provides managers with a more comprehensive understanding, helping them to more accurately assess employee performance in a team-based environment.
- **Future Research Directions**: It offers new perspectives for further research on other influencing factors in teamwork.
In summary, this paper, through detailed empirical analysis, reveals the significant impact of colleagues' performance on individual performance evaluations, providing new insights into the performance evaluation mechanisms in team-based environments.