Learners Teaching Novices: An Uplifting Alternative Assessment

Ali Malik,Juliette Woodrow,Chris Piech

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3626252.3630887

2024-03-22

Abstract:We propose and carry-out a novel method of formative assessment called Assessment via Teaching (AVT), in which learners demonstrate their understanding of CS1 topics by tutoring more novice students. AVT has powerful benefits over traditional forms of assessment: it is centered around service to others and is highly rewarding for the learners who teach. Moreover, teaching greatly improves the learners' own understanding of the material and has a huge positive impact on novices, who receive free 1:1 tutoring. Lastly, this form of assessment is naturally difficult to cheat -- a critical property for assessments in the era of large-language models.

Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve are several key issues in current educational assessment methods (such as written or oral examinations):

1. **Pressure on students and teachers**: Traditional assessment methods often make students feel stressed and have a poor experience, and teachers need to spend a great deal of time preparing and grading examinations.
2. **Authenticity and significance of assessment**: Students may feel that these assessments are disconnected from the actual learning content and lack authenticity and significance.
3. **Cheating problem**: With the rise of large - language models, cheating has become easier, which poses a threat to the fairness of assessment.

To solve these problems, the author proposes a new formative assessment method - **Assessment via Teaching (AVT)**. The core idea of this method is to let students demonstrate and deepen their understanding of the course content by teaching more junior students. Specifically, AVT has the following advantages:

- **Service - oriented and meaningful**: Students feel a sense of accomplishment in helping others while enhancing their own understanding.
- **Difficult to cheat**: Since the content and questions in each teaching are different, it is difficult for students to deal with the assessment by rote memorization.
- **In - depth feedback**: The process of explaining concepts can help students discover and correct their own misunderstandings, thus deepening their understanding.
- **Repeatability**: Students can participate in AVT multiple times and continuously improve their knowledge and skills.

To verify the effectiveness of AVT, the author conducted a randomized controlled trial (RCT) in an introductory computer science course (CS1). The results show that students participating in AVT performed significantly better in the examination than the control group, especially on topics related to AVT. In addition, AVT also increased students' motivation for preparation and satisfaction with the learning experience.

In summary, this paper aims to explore a more positive, meaningful and difficult - to - cheat alternative assessment method to improve the deficiencies in the current educational assessment system.