Post‐operative paradoxical vocal cord movement due to non‐organic conversion disorder
V. Rewari
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1399-6576.2006.01055.x
2006-08-01
Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica
Abstract:Sir, In my practice of anaesthesiology in patients undergoing surgical intervention for primary infertility, I have come across some patients, especially those with a long-standing history of infertility, who develop acute inspiratory stridor in the immediate post-operative period. Initially, these patients presented a diagnostic dilemma, as all were healthy young women who had had an uneventful intra-operative course. Post-operatively, they were fully awake with complete neuromuscular recovery, were able to phonate well and often complained about difficulty in breathing. This was not associated with a fall in oxygen saturation at any point, and no obvious laryngeal or tracheal pathology was detected. The first two patients were managed by giving continuous positive airway pressure through a face mask, and the stridor was finally relieved after 30 min of patient mask holding. In the next patient who developed similar symptoms, the diagnosis was finally reached by nasal fibreoptic laryngoscopy, which revealed adduction of the true vocal cords during inspiration causing the stridor. The condition was diagnosed as paradoxical vocal cord motion (PVCM). Subsequently, these patients were managed with verbal assurance and intravenous midazolam if required. Acute inspiratory stridor in the post-operative period is a cause for serious concern and requires the immediate attention of an anaesthesiologist. PVCM is one of the less common causes of post-operative stridor and hence is often overlooked in favour of more common causes, such as laryngeal spasm, intubation injury, angio-oedema, etc. PVCM is a form of laryngeal dyskinesia characterized by inappropriate adduction of the true vocal cords during inspiration. The laryngeal adductor muscles may be partially activated during normal inspiration, but the contraction of these muscles is markedly increased in PVCM and results in inspiratory stridor (1). The origin of PVCM is multifactorial and may be a result of both organic and non-organic causes. Organic causes of PVCM, such as brainstem compression, neurological compromise, movement disorders and gastro-oesophageal reflux, were ruled out in these patients, and hence the cause of PVCM was non-organic in nature. Non-organic PVCM can occur as a result of malingering disorders or conversion disorder (1). In malingering disorders, PVCM is consciously produced for secondary gain, whereas in conversion disorder it is unintentional (2). There are no obvious external incentives to account for malingering in these patients, and hence PVCM is probably due to non-organic somatization or conversion disorder as a result of the underlying emotional distress of long-standing infertility. Non-organic PVCM is more common in young women, most of whom meet the diagnostic criteria for a psychological disorder (3). Infertility in women is associated with a higher incidence of psychological problems, such as anxiety and depression, and the risk factors include a 2to 3-year history of infertility, repeated treatment cycles, unsuccessful treatments, low socioeconomic status and a lack of partner support (4, 5). In many parts of the Indian subcontinent, infertility in women is considered a social taboo, and such women may be subjected to mental and physical abuse by the husband and his family. These women harbour considerable anxiety and often are in a state of depression, the somatization of which could be a possible cause of the precipitation of PVCM in the postoperative period. The characteristics of non-organic PVCM due to a conversion disorder are as follows: (i) it occurs in a fully awake patient; (ii) it does not affect the oxygenation of the patient; (iii) the patient is able to phonate well; and (iv) the stridor improves with verbal assurance. The diagnosis can be confirmed by fibreoptic visualization of the vocal cords, and adduction of the true vocal cords during inspiration confirms the diagnosis of PVCM. Therefore, it is suggested that PVCM should be considered as a differential diagnosis of post-operative stridor in patients who have no evidence of functional or organic anomaly of the airway, but have underlying anxiety, depression or other psychological disorder.