On Equilibrium Determinacy in Overlapping Generations Models with Money

Tomohiro Hirano,Alexis Akira Toda

2024-03-20

Abstract:This paper provides a detailed analysis of the local determinacy of monetary and non-monetary steady states in Tirole (1985)'s classical two-period overlapping generations model with capital and production. We show that the sufficient condition for local determinacy in endowment economies provided by Scheinkman (1980) does not generalize to models with production: there are robust examples with arbitrary utility functions in which the non-monetary steady state is locally determinate or indeterminate. In contrast, the monetary steady state is locally determinate under fairly weak conditions.

Theoretical Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses the deterministic equilibrium problem in overlapping generations (OLG) models with money. The author analyzes the local determinacy of monetary and non-monetary steady states in Tirole's (1985) classic model and points out that the sufficient condition given by Scheinkman (1980) does not apply to production economies, i.e., the local determinacy of non-monetary steady states cannot be solely determined by the utility function. The paper demonstrates that even in the simple setup of Cobb-Douglas utility and constant elasticity of substitution production functions, the local determinacy of non-monetary steady states can be achieved for any case by choosing appropriate production function parameters. On the other hand, the monetary steady state is always locally determined as long as certain weaker conditions are satisfied.

The main findings of the paper include:
1. In production economies, the local determinacy of non-monetary steady states is not solely determined by the utility function alone and can be constructed with determinacy or indeterminacy by carefully choosing the production functions.
2. The monetary steady state is always locally determined under weaker conditions.
3. The paper further illustrates the theoretical results through examples of Cobb-Douglas and constant elasticity of substitution production functions, showing that even in this standard setting, the local determinacy of non-monetary steady states can exhibit arbitrary behavior, while the monetary steady state is always locally determined. There also exists a locally indeterminate non-monetary steady state and a possible unstable state.

These findings emphasize the necessity of combining intuition with mathematical analysis when analyzing the equilibrium of OLG models, as monetary economies are inherently unstable and have continuous equilibrium paths.