Abstract:In this chapter, we study the consistency of the value of information$\unicode{x2014}$a semantic metric that claims to determine the right piece of information in networked control systems tasks$\unicode{x2014}$in a lossy and delayed communication regime. Our analysis begins with a focus on state estimation, and subsequently extends to feedback control. To that end, we make a causal tradeoff between the packet rate and the mean square error. Associated with this tradeoff, we demonstrate the existence of an optimal policy profile, comprising a symmetric threshold scheduling policy based on the value of information for the encoder and a non-Gaussian linear estimation policy for the decoder. Our structural results assert that the scheduling policy is expressible in terms of $3d-1$ variables related to the source and the channel, where $d$ is the time delay, and that the estimation policy incorporates no residual related to signaling. We then construct an optimal control policy by exploiting the separation principle.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper This paper aims to investigate the consistency issue of "Value of Information" (VoI) in communication environments with packet loss and delay. Specifically, the authors focus on how to determine the correct information fragments through "Value of Information" in network control system tasks under the influence of packet loss and delay. The paper starts with state estimation and then extends to feedback control. ### Background and Motivation Packet loss and delay are common network defects in network control systems, which can severely affect the overall performance of the system and even lead to system instability. Therefore, any semantic-aware approach that aims to integrate communication objectives into the design process needs to have the ability to counter these defects. This paper attempts to address these issues by studying the consistency of "Value of Information." ### Main Contributions 1. **State Estimation**: - The authors study the state estimation problem of partially observable Gaussian-Markov processes in a communication environment with packet loss and delay, proposing a causal trade-off problem between packet rate and mean square error. - It is proven that there exists an optimal strategy configuration, including a symmetric threshold scheduling strategy based on the value of information and a non-Gaussian linear estimation strategy. - The results show that the scheduling strategy can be represented by $3d-1$ variables related to the source and channel, where $d$ is the delay, while the estimation strategy does not contain residuals related to the signal. 2. **Feedback Control**: - By utilizing the separation principle, an optimal control strategy is constructed. - It is proven that in the feedback control problem, the optimal control strategy is an equivalent deterministic strategy, and its scheduling strategy has the same structure as the scheduling strategy in state estimation. ### Numerical Example To verify the effectiveness of the proposed framework, the authors provide a numerical example demonstrating how to use the optimal scheduling strategy based on the value of information in practical applications. This example particularly focuses on the control problem of a spin-stabilized spacecraft, showcasing the performance of the scheduling and control strategies under different scenarios. ### Conclusion By studying the consistency of "Value of Information," this paper proposes a method to optimize the performance of network control systems in communication environments with packet loss and delay. Through state estimation and feedback control, the effectiveness and superiority of the proposed scheduling and control strategies are demonstrated. These results provide a theoretical foundation for designing robust and high-performance network control systems.

Consistency of Value of Information: Effects of Packet Loss and Time Delay in Networked Control Systems Tasks

Controllability analysis of Networked Control Systems with packets loss

Value of Information in Networked Control Systems Subject to Delay

Optimal Estimation and Control for Lossy Network: Stability, Convergence, and Performance

On Stability and Convergence of Optimal Estimation for Networked Control Systems with Dual Packet Losses Without Acknowledgment

Optimal Estimation for Networked Control Systems with Intermittent Inputs without Acknowledgement

Networked Control with Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request Protocols

On Stability and Convergence of Suboptimal Estimation for Systems over Lossy Networks Without Acknowledgement

Interacting Multiple Model Estimator for Networked Control Systems: Stability, Convergence, and Performance

Latency-Reliability Tradeoffs for State Estimation

Fast Filtering Algorithm for State Estimation of Lossy Networks

Optimal control for networked control system with Markovian packet loss and delay

Consensus control and initialization region optimization for leader‐following multi‐agent systems under time‐varying communication delay and consecutive packet dropouts

Robust Control Invariance and Communication Scheduling in Lossy Wireless Networked Control Systems

Stochastic Analysis and Synthesis of Networked Systems With Consecutively Lost Packets

Networked LQG control over lossy channels with computational/packet-transmission delays and coarsely quantised packets

Analysis and synthesis for networked control systems with uncertain rate of packet losses

The Effect of Time Delay on the Average Data Rate and Performance in Networked Control Systems

Optimal Tracking of Networked Control Systems over the Fading Channel with Packet Loss

Discrete-Time Sliding-Mode Congestion Control in Multisource Communication Networks With Time-Varying Delay

Consensusability of Discrete-Time Multiagent Systems with Communication Delay and Packet Dropouts