A non-surjective Wigner-type theorem in terms of equivalent pairs of subspaces

Mark Pankov
2024-03-16
Abstract:Let $H$ be an infinite-dimensional complex Hilbert space and let ${\mathcal G}_{\infty}(H)$ be the set of all closed subspaces of $H$ whose dimension and codimension both are infinite. We investigate (not necessarily surjective) transformations of ${\mathcal G}_{\infty}(H)$ sending every pair of subspaces to an equivalent pair of subspaces; two pairs of subspaces are equivalent if there is a linear isometry sending one of these pairs to the other. Let $f$ be such a transformation. We show that there is a unique up to a scalar multiple linear or conjugate linear isometry $L:H\to H$ such that for every $X\in {\mathcal G}_{\infty}(H)$ the image $f(X)$ is the sum of $L(X)$ and a certain closed subspace $O(X)$ orthogonal to the range of $L$. In the case when $H$ is separable, we give the following sufficient condition to assert that $f$ is induced by a linear or conjugate linear isometry: if $O(X)=0$ for a certain $X\in {\mathcal G}_{\infty}(H)$, then the same holds for all $X\in {\mathcal G}_{\infty}(H)$.
Mathematical Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study the properties of (not necessarily surjective) transformations \(f\) in the infinite - dimensional complex Hilbert space \(H\), for the Grassmannian \(G^\infty(H)\) of all closed subspaces, when both the dimension and codimension are infinite. These transformations map each pair of subspaces to an equivalent pair of subspaces, that is, there exists a linear isometric isomorphism that maps one pair of subspaces to the other pair. Specifically, the main objective of the paper is to prove that for such a transformation \(f\), there exists a unique (up to a scalar multiple) linear or conjugate - linear isometric isomorphism \(L: H\rightarrow H\) such that for each \(X\in G^\infty(H)\), the image \(f(X)\) is the direct sum of \(L(X)\) and a closed subspace \(O(X)\) orthogonal to the range of \(L\), that is: \[f(X)=L(X)\oplus O(X)\] Furthermore, if \(H\) is separable and \(O(X) = 0\) for some \(X\in G^\infty(H)\), then \(O(X)=0\) for all \(X\in G^\infty(H)\). In this case, the transformation \(f\) can be induced by a linear or conjugate - linear isometric isomorphism. The paper also explores whether the above conclusion holds in the non - separable case and points out that in the non - separable case, since the Grassmannian contains subspaces of different dimensions, the same conclusion cannot be proved. ### Main Results 1. **Theorem 1**: For the transformation \(f\), there exists a unique (up to a scalar multiple) linear or conjugate - linear isometric isomorphism \(L: H\rightarrow H\) such that for each \(X\in G^\infty(H)\), the image \(f(X)\) is the direct sum of \(L(X)\) and a closed subspace \(O(X)\) orthogonal to the range of \(L\). - If \(X, Y\) belong to the same connected component, then \(O(X)=O(Y)\). - If \(Y\subset X\), then \(O(Y)\subset O(X)\). 2. **Theorem 2**: If \(H\) is separable and \(O(X) = 0\) for some \(X\in G^\infty(H)\), then \(O(X)=0\) for all \(X\in G^\infty(H)\) and the transformation \(f\) can be induced by a linear or conjugate - linear isometric isomorphism. ### Proof Methods - **Lemma 1**: The transformation \(f\) preserves the inclusion relation. - **Lemma 2**: For each \(X\in G^\infty(H)\), there exists a unique (up to a scalar multiple) linear or conjugate - linear isometric isomorphism \(L_X:X\rightarrow f(X)\) such that for each \(Y\in G_{\text{fin}}(X)\), \(f(Y)=L_X(Y)\oplus O(X)\). - **Lemma 3**: There exists a linear or conjugate - linear isometric isomorphism \(L: H\rightarrow H\) such that for each \(X\in G^\infty(H)\), the restriction of \(L\) on \(X\) is a scalar multiple of \(L_X\) and \(O(X)\) is orthogonal to the range of \(L\). - **Lemma 4**: If \(H\) is separable, for each \(X\in G^\infty(H)\), there exists \(Q\in G^\infty(H)\) such that \(Q\) and \(Q^{\perp}\) intersect \(X^{\perp}\) only at zero. Through these lemmas, the paper gradually proves the main theorems and reveals the structure of the transformation \(f\) and its relationship with linear or conjugate - linear isometric isomorphisms.