Reviewing AI's Role in Non-Muscle-Invasive Bladder Cancer Recurrence Prediction

Saram Abbas,Rishad Shafik,Naeem Soomro,Rakesh Heer,Kabita Adhikari

2024-09-16

Abstract:Notorious for its 70-80% recurrence rate, Non-muscle-invasive Bladder Cancer (NMIBC) imposes a significant human burden and is one of the costliest cancers to manage. Current tools for predicting NMIBC recurrence rely on scoring systems that often overestimate risk and have poor accuracy. This is where Machine learning (ML)-based techniques have emerged as a promising approach for predicting NMIBC recurrence by leveraging molecular and clinical data. This comprehensive review paper critically analyses ML-based frameworks for predicting NMIBC recurrence, focusing on their statistical robustness and algorithmic efficacy. We meticulously examine the strengths and weaknesses of each study, by focusing on various prediction tasks, data modalities, and ML models, highlighting their remarkable performance alongside inherent limitations. A diverse array of ML algorithms that leverage multimodal data spanning radiomics, clinical, histopathological, and genomic data, exhibit significant promise in accurately predicting NMIBC recurrence. However, the path to widespread adoption faces challenges concerning the generalisability and interpretability of models, emphasising the need for collaborative efforts, robust datasets, and the incorporation of cost-effectiveness. Our detailed categorisation and in-depth analysis illuminate the nuances, complexities, and contexts that influence real-world advancement and adoption of these AI-based techniques. This rigorous analysis equips researchers with a deeper understanding of the intricacies of the ML algorithms employed. Researchers can use these insights to refine approaches, address limitations, and boost generalisability of their ML models, ultimately leading to reduced healthcare costs and improved patient outcomes.

Machine Learning,Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the high recurrence rate of non - muscle - invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC). Specifically, the recurrence rate of NMIBC is as high as 70 - 80%, which brings a huge burden to patients and the medical system. Currently, the tools used to predict NMIBC recurrence mainly rely on scoring systems, which often overestimate the risk and have poor accuracy. Therefore, this review paper aims to explore the application of machine - learning (ML) techniques in predicting NMIBC recurrence, in order to improve the accuracy and reliability of prediction.

### Main problems
1. **High recurrence rate**: NMIBC has an extremely high recurrence rate (70 - 80%), causing patients to need to undergo invasive examinations (such as cystoscopy) frequently. This not only increases the pain and economic burden of patients but also exerts great pressure on medical resources.
2. **Limitations of existing tools**: Traditional prediction tools (such as the TNM staging system, the EORTC risk table, and the CUETO scoring system) perform poorly in predicting NMIBC recurrence, with a high false - positive rate and low accuracy.

### Solutions
The paper reviews and analyzes the existing machine - learning - based prediction frameworks, evaluates their statistical robustness and algorithmic performance, to find more effective prediction methods. Specifically, it includes:
- **Application of multi - modal data**: Combine imaging, clinical, histopathological, and genomics data, and use various machine - learning algorithms (such as support vector machines, random forests, artificial neural networks, and deep learning) to build prediction models.
- **Improve prediction accuracy**: Improve the feature selection, model training, and validation processes to enhance the accuracy and generalization ability of prediction models.
- **Solve the deficiencies of existing tools**: In view of the limitations of traditional tools, propose new solutions, such as introducing molecular markers and complex bioinformatics data, to achieve more accurate prediction.

### Goals
The ultimate goal is to develop a more reliable and accurate tool that can effectively predict the recurrence of NMIBC, thereby reducing unnecessary invasive examinations, optimizing treatment regimens, reducing medical costs, and improving the prognosis and quality of life of patients.

### Conclusions
Through systematic literature review and analysis, the paper reveals the great potential of machine learning in predicting NMIBC recurrence, and also points out the challenges in current research and future development directions. This provides valuable references for researchers and helps promote the further development of this field.