AI-enhanced Collective Intelligence

Hao Cui,Taha Yasseri

2024-09-26

Abstract:Current societal challenges exceed the capacity of humans operating either alone or collectively. As AI evolves, its role within human collectives will vary from an assistive tool to a participatory member. Humans and AI possess complementary capabilities that, together, can surpass the collective intelligence of either humans or AI in isolation. However, the interactions in human-AI systems are inherently complex, involving intricate processes and interdependencies. This review incorporates perspectives from complex network science to conceptualize a multilayer representation of human-AI collective intelligence, comprising cognition, physical, and information layers. Within this multilayer network, humans and AI agents exhibit varying characteristics; humans differ in diversity from surface-level to deep-level attributes, while AI agents range in degrees of functionality and anthropomorphism. We explore how agents' diversity and interactions influence the system's collective intelligence and analyze real-world instances of AI-enhanced collective intelligence. We conclude by considering potential challenges and future developments in this field.

Computers and Society,Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is how to effectively integrate Artificial Intelligence (AI) into human collective intelligence to enhance the problem-solving capabilities of human collectives. Specifically, the paper explores the interaction patterns between humans and AI in different task environments and how these interactions affect the performance of collective intelligence. The paper emphasizes the importance of complementary capabilities between humans and AI, pointing out that by effectively combining the strengths of both, it is possible to surpass the level of collective intelligence that either humans or AI alone can achieve.

The paper also focuses on the following aspects:
1. **The concept of collective intelligence**: Defines collective intelligence and distinguishes it from "group wisdom," emphasizing that collective intelligence is not merely the simple aggregation of individual opinions but is generated through complex interactive processes to produce higher intelligence.
2. **The development of AI and its impact on collective intelligence**: Discusses how the development of AI technology changes the way human society collaborates, particularly in areas such as information processing and decision support.
3. **The complexity of human-AI hybrid systems**: Proposes a multi-layer network model to describe the interactions between humans and AI, including cognitive, physical, and information layers, and analyzes how the interactions between these layers affect the formation of collective intelligence.
4. **The relationship between diversity and collective intelligence**: Explores the impact of team diversity (including surface-level and deep-level diversity) on collective intelligence, pointing out the positive and negative effects of diversity factors such as gender, age, and race on team performance in different contexts.
5. **Future challenges and development directions**: Discusses the main challenges faced in designing and implementing AI-enhanced collective intelligence systems, such as technical, ethical, and social acceptance issues, and looks forward to future research directions in this field.

Overall, this paper aims to provide scientific basis and practical guidance for understanding and optimizing human-AI hybrid collective intelligence systems through theoretical analysis and empirical research.