Abstract:Over the last several years, several well-established and prominent brick-and-mortar retail chains have ceased operations, raising concerns for something that some have referred to as a retail apocalypse. While the demise of brick-and-mortar is far from certain, scholars have attempted to model the likelihood that a retailer is about to fail using different approaches. This paper examines the failures of Bed Bath and Beyond, J.C. Penney, Rite Aid, and Sears Holdings in the United States between 2013 and 2022. A model of retail failure is presented that considers internal and external firm factors using both annual report and macroeconomic data. The findings suggest that certain revenue-based financial ratios and the annual average U.S. inflation rates are statistically significant predictors of failure. Furthermore, the failure model demonstrated that it can provide a nontrivial early warning signal at least the year before failure. The paper concludes with a discussion and directions for future research.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of predicting the bankruptcy risk of brick-and-mortar retail chains. Specifically, the authors constructed a predictive model by analyzing the bankruptcy cases of several well-known brick-and-mortar retail chains in the United States from 2013 to 2022 (such as Bed Bath and Beyond, J.C. Penney, Rite Aid, and Sears Holdings). The model aims to assess the likelihood of retail chain bankruptcy through internal and external factors (including financial ratios and macroeconomic indicators) and provide early warning signals to help relevant stakeholders (such as investors, suppliers, and corporate leaders) take timely measures to reduce potential losses and business relationship tensions. ### Main Research Questions: 1. **Construction of the Predictive Model**: How to construct an effective predictive model for retail chain bankruptcy using internal and external factors? 2. **Identification of Key Factors**: Which financial ratios and macroeconomic indicators are important predictors of retail chain bankruptcy? 3. **Early Warning Signals**: Can the model provide non-trivial early warning signals one year before the chain's bankruptcy? ### Research Background: In recent years, many well-known brick-and-mortar retail chains have gone bankrupt, triggering the so-called "retail apocalypse" phenomenon. These bankruptcies have not only affected employees but also caused severe financial consequences for suppliers, investors, and property managers. Therefore, being able to predict the bankruptcy risk of retail chains in advance is crucial for relevant stakeholders. ### Research Methods: - **Data Sources**: Extract financial data from publicly available SEC 10-K annual reports, including revenue, costs, number of stores, etc.; obtain consumer satisfaction scores from the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI); extract U.S. average interest rates and inflation rates from macroeconomic data. - **Model Construction**: Use logistic regression analysis to construct the predictive model, considering internal factors (such as EBITDA/revenue, SGA/revenue, etc.) and external factors (such as inflation rate, pandemic years, etc.). - **Result Validation**: Estimate the bankruptcy probability of each retail chain for each year using the model and compare it with the actual bankruptcy situation to validate the model's effectiveness. ### Research Findings: - **Internal Factors**: EBITDA/revenue and SGA/revenue are important internal predictors. - **External Factors**: The U.S. average inflation rate is a significant external predictor. - **Early Warning**: The model can provide non-trivial early warning signals one year before the chain's bankruptcy, especially for Bed Bath and Beyond and Rite Aid. ### Conclusion: This study provides an effective predictive model for retail chain bankruptcy, which can help relevant stakeholders identify potential bankruptcy risks in advance and take corresponding risk management measures. Future research can further explore more predictive indicators and methods to improve the model's accuracy and practicality.

Prediction of retail chain failure: examples of recent U.S. retail failures

Using gravity model to make store closing decisions: A data driven approach

Role of Distribution Centers Disruptions in New Retail Supply Chain: An Analysis Experiment

Predicting corporate bankruptcy: where we stand?

Bank efficiency and failure prediction: a nonparametric and dynamic model based on data envelopment analysis

Why do banks fail? An investigation via text mining

Predicting corporate failure: some empirical evidence from the UK

Store survival in online marketplace: An empirical investigation

Predicting corporate bankruptcy using the framework of Leland-Toft: evidence from U.S.

The Potential of New Retail Models: Financial Analysis of JD and Suning Supply Chain Management Capabilities

Store survival in online marketplace

Linking inventory efficiency, productivity and responsiveness to retail firm outperformance: empirical insights from US retailing segments

Financial Distress Prediction Study in Retail Companies

Business Analysis of Walmart - Success Factors and Challenges

FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF RETAIL COMPANIES USING THE ALTMAN, SPRINGATE, ZMIJEWSKI, FULMER, AND GROVER BANKRUPTCY PREDICTION MODELS

Relationship between Home Depot and Lowe’s Under Impact of Major Events

Equilibrium in Style: A Modeling Framework on the Cash Flow and the Life Cycle of a Consumer Store

Learning from Failure: How to Succeed in the Chinese Retailing Market

The financial crash of 2020 and the retail trader’s boon: a correlation between sentiment and technical analysis

Utilizing artificial neural networks to predict demand for weather-sensitive products at retail stores

Predicting Bank Failures: A Synthesis of Literature and Directions for Future Research