Spiral to stripe transition in the two-dimensional Hubbard model

Robin Scholle,Walter Metzner,Demetrio Vilardi,Pietro M. Bonetti

2024-03-15

Abstract:We obtain an almost complete understanding of the mean-field phase diagram of the two-dimensional Hubbard model on a square lattice with a sizable next-nearest neighbor hopping and a moderate interaction strength. In particular, we clarify the nature of the transition region between the spiral and the stripe phase. Complementing previous [Phys. Rev. B 108, 035139 (2023)] real-space Hartree-Fock calculations on large finite lattices, we solve the mean-field equations for coplanar unidirectional magnetic order directly in the thermodynamic limit, and we determine the nature of the magnetic states right below the mean-field critical temperature $T^*$ by a Landau free energy analysis. While the magnetic order for filling factors $n \geq 1$ is always of Néel type, for $n \leq 1$ the following sequence of magnetic states is found as a function of increasing hole-doping: Néel, planar circular spiral, multi-spiral, and collinear spin-charge stripe states. Multi-spiral states are superpositions of several spirals with distinct wave vectors, and lead to concomitant charge order. We finally point out that nematic and charge orders inherited from the magnetic order can survive even in the presence of fluctuations, and we present a corresponding qualitative phase diagram.

Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly explores the transition from the spiral phase to the stripe phase in the two-dimensional Hubbard model. The Hubbard model is an important prototype model in the study of strongly correlated electron systems, as it captures key features such as antiferromagnetism and d-wave superconductivity in copper oxide high-temperature superconductors. Although some phase diagrams of this model have been understood through computational techniques, many regions of its parameter space are still unknown.

In the density range near half-filling (i.e. electron density of about 1), there is competition and possible coexistence among magnetism, charge order, and superconductivity. At half-filling, the ground state is a simple Néel antiferromagnetic phase. When the electron density deviates from half-filling, most calculations indicate the existence of a planar spiral phase or a stripe phase with collinear spin and accompanying charge order.

In this paper, the authors use three complementary methods to calculate the mean-field phase diagram at zero temperature and finite temperature, and determine the properties of different magnetic states. First, they directly solve the mean-field equations for a plane unidirectional magnetic phase with arbitrary integer periodicity in the thermodynamic limit. Secondly, they determine the magnetic ordering patterns below the critical temperature T* through Landau free energy analysis. Finally, they analyze the instability of the spiral phase with increasing hole doping to determine the transition process to the stripe phase.

The study found that the transition from the spiral phase to the stripe phase undergoes an intermediate stage with multiple spiral phases with different wave vectors. Furthermore, even in the presence of fluctuation effects, nematic (columnar) and charge orders inherited from magnetic order may survive.

In conclusion, this paper provides a more comprehensive understanding of the magnetic phase transition in the two-dimensional Hubbard model, particularly in the transition between stripe and spiral phases, which is of great significance for understanding the physics of copper oxide high-temperature superconductors and other strongly correlated electron systems.