Dimensional analysis in forest mensuration

Tim Davis,Huw Williams

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.15306.34248

2023-12-11

Abstract:We apply dimensional analysis with Buckinghams "Pi" theorem to estimate the volume of wood in a tree stem, given the tree's height and diameter. We use Meyer's (1953) data on 31 cherry trees from the Allegheny National forest as the main example, and extend our model to look at other forest mensuration data sets.

History and Overview

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores how to predict the volume of Black Cherry trees using statistical methods without the need to cut them down. Specifically, the study focuses on creating a predictive model using two easily measurable variables: diameter (measured at breast height) and height. The core contributions of the paper include:

1. **Dataset Background**: The dataset used in the paper comes from a 1953 forestry book and includes diameter, height, and actual volume information for 31 Black Cherry trees from the Allegheny National Forest in Pennsylvania.

2. **Statistical Modeling**: The paper discusses several different statistical modeling methods, including regression models based on logarithmic transformations and models established through dimensional analysis. Among these, the dimensional analysis model is formally similar to the volume formulas for cones or cylinders, but the actual results lie between the two, closer to the shape of a "frustum of a cone."

3. **Application of Dimensional Analysis**: The paper emphasizes the importance of dimensional analysis, which can reduce the number of variables in the model and yield a more concise and physically meaningful model. Using Buckingham's π theorem, the paper simplifies the original problem into a relationship between two dimensionless variables, resulting in a model that is simple in form but clear in physical meaning.

4. **Model Interpretation and Validation**: The paper proposes a new way of interpreting the model by viewing it as a "frustum of a cone" and validates the model's effectiveness by comparing it with existing studies on the morphology of Black Cherry trees. Additionally, it discusses how measurement errors can affect the accuracy of volume predictions.

5. **Model Generalizability**: By applying the model to datasets of other tree species (such as Shortleaf Pine), the paper demonstrates that the model is not only applicable to Black Cherry trees but also has a certain degree of applicability to other types of trees.

In summary, the paper aims to address an important practical issue in forestry management—how to predict the volume of trees without cutting them down—using statistical methods to support more effective forest resource management and utilization.