Partitioning Distribution Networks for Integrated Electrification Planning

Olamide Oladeji,Pedro Ciller Cutillas,Fernando de Cuadra,Ignacio Perez-Arriaga

2024-03-14

Abstract:In many developing countries, access to electricity remains a significant challenge. Electrification planners in these countries often have to make important decisions on the mode of electrification and the planning of electrical networks for those without access, while under resource constraints. An integrated approach to electrification planning in which traditional grid electrification is complemented off-the-grid technologies such as off-grid microgrids and stand-alone systems can enable the economic provision of electricity access in these regions. This integrated planning approach can be facilitated by determining the least-cost mode of electrification - i.e by electric grid extension or off-grid systems - for non-electrified consumers in a region under analysis, while considering technical, economic and environmental constraints. Computational clustering methods the identification of consumer clusters (either as clusters of off-grid microgrids, stand-alone systems or grid-extension projects) can be undertaken using computational clustering methods. This paper presents a novel computational approach to achieve this purpose. This methodology involves exploiting the grid network that connects all consumers, by greedily partitioning the network to identify clusters of consumers to be electrified by grid-extension and off-grid microgrid systems. Using test cases and sensitivity analyses, we implement and benchmark this top-down approach with those obtained from a bottom-up clustering methodology used by the Reference Electrification Model, a model obtainable in literature. Results presented show that the alternative top-down methodology proposed can compare favorably, in terms of global electrification costs, with a bottom-up approach to rural electrification planning.

Systems and Control,Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper focuses on the challenges of electricity access in developing countries, particularly how to plan electrification in resource-limited settings. The author proposes an integrated electrification planning approach that combines traditional grid extension with off-grid technologies such as off-grid microgrids and standalone systems to economically provide electricity services. The core question of the paper is to determine the most cost-effective electrification mode, i.e., deciding which areas should be electrified through grid extension and which should adopt off-grid systems.

Specifically, the paper introduces a novel computation method that identifies clusters of consumers to be served by grid extension and off-grid microgrid systems by greedily partitioning the electricity network. This method considers technical, economic, and environmental constraints and compares it with existing bottom-up clustering methods like the Reference Electrification Model (REM) through test cases and sensitivity analysis. The results show that the proposed top-down approach can be competitive with the bottom-up approach in overall electrification cost.

The tools and models mentioned in the paper, such as Network Planner, LAPER, IntiGIS, and GEOSIM, have limitations to varying degrees, such as the lack of detailed analysis of individual buildings or consumers, not computing the optimal consumer clusters, and not including detailed network design. REM attempts to address these issues through a finer-grained approach using bottom-up clustering algorithms, but the paper proposes an alternative top-down network partitioning method that starts from a fully connected network to the grid and then partitions based on cost parameters to find cheaper planning configurations.

In conclusion, the paper aims to improve and develop computational methods for rural electrification planning to more efficiently allocate resources, reduce costs, and promote global energy access.