Abstract:This note shows that adaptive strategies do not offer additional advantages for learning and testing Pauli channels with entangled input. First, the tight query complexity of learning Pauli channels with entangled input is established for the general norm $l_p$. In particular, the complexities for the $l_{1}$, $l_2$ and $l_\infty$ norms are improved or matched compared to previous results using entanglement in the literature. We also settle the query complexity to test if Pauli channels are white noise sources across $l_p$. Additionally, we demonstrate that the query complexity of estimating the noise level of a Pauli channel, characterized by the entropy of its error distribution and the count of non-zero probabilities, is $\Theta(4^n/n)$. Further, $\Theta(4^n/n)$ queries are sufficient to estimate the diamond norm between two Pauli channels.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore whether adaptive strategies can provide additional advantages in quantum channel learning, especially in the learning and testing of Pauli channels. Through research, the author found that when using entangled inputs, adaptive strategies do not bring more benefits than non - adaptive strategies. Specifically, the paper addresses the following issues:
1. **Query complexity of Pauli channel learning**:
- The paper established the tight query complexity for learning Pauli channels using entangled inputs, which is applicable to the general \( l_p \) norm. In particular, for the \( l_1 \), \( l_2 \) and \( l_\infty \) norms, the paper improved or matched the results in the existing literature using entangled resources.
- The specific complexities are as follows:
- For the \( l_1 \) norm, the complexity is \( \Theta(4^n / \epsilon^2) \).
- For the \( l_2 \) norm, the complexity is \( \Theta(1 / \epsilon^2) \).
- For the \( l_\infty \) norm, the complexity is \( \Theta(1 / \epsilon^2) \).
2. **Query complexity of testing whether a Pauli channel is a white noise source**:
- The paper determined the query complexity of testing whether a Pauli channel is a white noise source, which is applicable to different \( l_p \) norms.
3. **Estimating the noise level of Pauli channels**:
- The paper showed that the query complexity required to estimate the noise level of Pauli channels (characterized by the entropy of its error distribution and the number of non - zero probabilities) is \( \Theta(4^n / n\epsilon^2) \).
- Further, the paper proved that \( \Theta(4^n / n\epsilon^2) \) queries are sufficient to estimate the diamond - norm distance between two Pauli channels.
4. **Effectiveness of adaptive strategies**:
- The paper showed through theoretical analysis and experimental results that in the case of using entangled resources, adaptive strategies do not provide additional benefits compared to non - adaptive strategies. This is mainly because each application of the Pauli channel can directly generate a sample, and the subsequent operations are all classical processing procedures and do not involve adaptive adjustment.
### Main conclusions
- **No advantage of adaptive strategies**: In the case of using entangled inputs, adaptive strategies do not provide additional advantages compared to non - adaptive strategies.
- **Tight complexity**: The paper established the tight query complexity for learning and testing Pauli channels, which is applicable to various \( l_p \) norms.
- **Noise level estimation**: The paper provided an effective method for estimating the noise level of Pauli channels, including the estimation of entropy and support size.
### Methods and techniques
- **Choi isomorphism**: Represent quantum channels using Choi isomorphism and detect Pauli errors through Bell measurements.
- **Sample complexity conversion**: Convert the learning complexity of discrete probability distributions into the query complexity of quantum channels.
- **Classical algorithms**: Use classical algorithms (such as "Estimate Unseen") to estimate the noise level.
Through these methods and techniques, the paper provides an important theoretical basis and practical tools for understanding and quantifying quantum noise in Pauli channels.