Managing Distributional Ambiguity in Stochastic Optimization through a Statistical Upper Bound Framework

Shixin Liu,Jian Hu
2024-04-19
Abstract:Stochastic optimization is often hampered by distributional ambiguity, where critical probability distributions are poorly characterized or unknown. Addressing this challenge, we introduce a new framework that targets the minimization of a statistical upper bound for the expected value of uncertain objectives, facilitating more statistically robust decision-making. Central to our approach is the Average Percentile Upper Bound (APUB), a novel construct that simultaneously delivers a statistically rigorous upper bound for the population mean and a meaningful risk metric for the sample mean. The integration of APUB into stochastic optimization not only fortifies the process against distributional ambiguity but also reinforces key data-driven decision-making attributes, such as reliability, consistency, and comprehensibility. Notably, APUB-enriched optimization problems feature tractability, with particular advantages in two-stage stochastic optimization with random recourse. Empirical demonstrations on two-stage product mix and multi-product newsvendor benchmark problems reveal the benefit of the APUB optimization framework, in comparison with conventional techniques such as sample average approximation and distributionally robust optimization.
Optimization and Control
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of handling distributional ambiguity in stochastic optimization. Specifically: 1. **Background Problem**: In engineering and management decision-making, handling uncertain parameters is a key challenge. Stochastic optimization models uncertain parameters as random variables, but in practical applications, precise estimation of probability distributions becomes very difficult due to limited data, incomplete information, and high system complexity. This discrepancy between theoretical models and practical constraints leads to the "Optimizer's Curse," where optimization under distributional ambiguity may result in suboptimal solutions. 2. **Research Objective**: This paper proposes a new framework to enhance the statistical robustness of decisions by minimizing the statistical upper bound of the uncertain objective function's expected value. The core idea is the introduction of a novel concept—the Average Percentile Upper Bound (APUB). APUB not only provides a statistically rigorous upper bound on the overall mean but also serves as a risk measure for the sample mean. By integrating APUB into stochastic optimization, it not only enhances resistance to distributional ambiguity but also improves key decision attributes such as reliability, consistency, and interpretability. 3. **Methodological Innovation**: Compared to other methods (such as Sample Average Approximation and Distributionally Robust Optimization), the APUB optimization framework offers better interpretability and practicality. Experimental results show that the APUB framework outperforms traditional techniques in benchmark problems like two-stage product portfolio and multi-product newsvendor problems. Additionally, APUB has particular advantages in two-stage stochastic optimization and enhances decision robustness by guiding decision-makers to formulate strategies that perform well under various possible distributional assumptions.