Invalid proxies and volatility changes

Giovanni Angelini,Luca Fanelli,Luca Neri

2024-03-14

Abstract:When in proxy-SVARs the covariance matrix of VAR disturbances is subject to exogenous, permanent, nonrecurring breaks that generate target impulse response functions (IRFs) that change across volatility regimes, even strong, exogenous external instruments can result in inconsistent estimates of the dynamic causal effects of interest if the breaks are not properly accounted for. In such cases, it is essential to explicitly incorporate the shifts in unconditional volatility in order to point-identify the target structural shocks and possibly restore consistency. We demonstrate that, under a necessary and sufficient rank condition that leverages moments implied by changes in volatility, the target IRFs can be point-identified and consistently estimated. Importantly, standard asymptotic inference remains valid in this context despite (i) the covariance between the proxies and the instrumented structural shocks being local-to-zero, as in Staiger and Stock (1997), and (ii) the potential failure of instrument exogeneity. We introduce a novel identification strategy that appropriately combines external instruments with "informative" changes in volatility, thus obviating the need to assume proxy relevance and exogeneity in estimation. We illustrate the effectiveness of the suggested method by revisiting a fiscal proxy-SVAR previously estimated in the literature, complementing the fiscal instruments with information derived from the massive reduction in volatility observed in the transition from the Great Inflation to the Great Moderation regimes.

Econometrics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper explores how to use external tools (proxy variables) to identify and estimate dynamic causal effects in structural vector autoregressive models (SVARs) when the covariance matrix changes due to exogenous, permanent, and non-recurring disruptions. The study suggests that even if the correlation between the external tools and structural shocks is weak or not fully exogenous, target impulse response functions can still be identified and consistently estimated by appropriately considering the changes in volatility. The paper proposes a new identification strategy that combines external tools and volatility transformations without assuming the correlation and exogeneity of proxy variables in advance. This approach is of significant importance for understanding structural disruptions and impulse responses in different volatility states within economic relationships.

Invalid proxies and volatility changes

Policymaker meetings as heteroscedasticity shifters: Identification and simultaneous inference in unstable SVARs

Robust Impulse Responses using External Instruments: the Role of Information

US fiscal policy shocks: Proxy‐SVAR overidentification via GMM

Estimating Fiscal Multipliers by Combining Statistical Identification with Potentially Endogenous Proxies

Multivariate Stochastic Volatility with Co-Heteroscedasticity

Identification and Estimation of Dynamic Causal Effects in Macroeconomics Using External Instruments

VAR Analysis and the Great Moderation

Vector Autoregressions with Dynamic Factor Coefficients and Conditionally Heteroskedastic Errors

Locally robust inference for non‐Gaussian SVAR models

Partially identified heteroskedastic SVARs

The systematic component of monetary policy in SVARs: An agnostic identification procedure

Identification of fiscal SVAR-IVs in small open economies

Generalized dynamic factor models and volatilities: Consistency, rates, and prediction intervals

Inference in Structural Vector Autoregressions identified with an external instrument

Identification of Vector Autoregressive Models with Nonlinear Contemporaneous Structure

Heteroskedastic Proxy Vector Autoregressions: An Identification-Robust Test for Time-Varying Impulse Responses in the Presence of Multiple Proxies

Generalized dynamic factor models and volatilities: recovering the market volatility shocks

Adaptive local VAR for dynamic economic policy uncertainty spillover

Efficient nonparametric estimation and inference for the volatility function

Simultaneous identification of fiscal and monetary policy shocks