Abstract:CrI3 is a prototypical van der Waals ferromagnet with a magnetic honeycomb lattice. Previous inelastic neutron scattering studies have suggested topological nature of its magnetic excitations with a magnon gap at the Dirac points, which are anticipated to give rise to magnon thermal Hall effect. Here we report thermal transport properties of CrI3 and show that the long-sought thermal Hall signal anticipated for topological magnons is fairly small. In contrast, we find that CrI3 exhibits an appreciable anomalous thermal Hall signal at lower temperature which may arise from magnon-phonon hybridization or magnon-phonon scattering. These findings are anticipated to stimulate further neutron scattering studies on CrI3 single crystal, which can shed light not only on the intrinsic nature of magnetic excitations but also on the magnon-phonon interaction.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is whether the Thermal Hall Effect (THE) in the 2D van der Waals ferromagnet CrI3 is caused by topological magnon excitations. Specifically, the researchers aim to experimentally measure the thermal transport properties of CrI3 to verify whether the theoretically predicted topological magnon excitations lead to a significant thermal Hall signal. ### Main Research Questions: 1. **Thermal Hall Effect of Topological Magnon Excitations**: CrI3 is a typical van der Waals ferromagnet with a honeycomb magnetic lattice. Previous inelastic neutron scattering studies have shown that the magnetic excitations in CrI3 have topological characteristics and exhibit a magnon gap at the Dirac point, suggesting the possibility of a topological magnon thermal Hall effect. However, this effect has not yet been observed experimentally. 2. **Source of Anomalous Thermal Hall Signal**: Researchers have found that CrI3 exhibits a significant anomalous thermal Hall signal at low temperatures, which may be due to magnon-phonon hybridization or magnon-phonon scattering. This finding differs from the expected topological magnon thermal Hall effect and requires further investigation to explain. ### Research Background: - **Topological Magnon Excitations**: In certain ferromagnetic materials, magnons (i.e., magnetic excitations) can exhibit topological properties similar to the behavior of electrons in topological insulators. These topological magnon excitations may lead to a thermal Hall effect. - **Characteristics of CrI3**: CrI3 is a layered ferromagnet with a honeycomb magnetic lattice. Previous studies have suggested that the magnetic excitations in CrI3 may have topological properties, but this has not been confirmed experimentally. ### Experimental Methods: - **Sample Preparation**: CrI3 single crystals were synthesized using the chemical vapor transport method. - **Thermal Transport Measurements**: Longitudinal and transverse thermal conductivities were measured using a one-heater-three-sensor technique. - **Magnetic Field Dependence**: The thermal Hall conductivity was studied under different temperatures and magnetic fields. ### Main Findings: 1. **Insignificant Topological Magnon Thermal Hall Effect**: In the high-temperature region, the expected topological magnon thermal Hall signal is very weak, much smaller than the theoretical prediction. 2. **Anomalous Thermal Hall Signal at Low Temperatures**: At low temperatures, CrI3 exhibits a significant anomalous thermal Hall signal, which may be due to magnon-phonon hybridization or magnon-phonon scattering. ### Conclusion: - **Small Topological Magnon Thermal Hall Signal**: The results indicate that the topological magnon thermal Hall signal in CrI3 is very small, possibly due to weak intrinsic DM interactions or the synergistic effects of interlayer coupling and intralayer interactions. - **Anomalous Thermal Hall Signal at Low Temperatures**: The anomalous thermal Hall signal at low temperatures may originate from magnon-phonon hybridization or magnon-phonon scattering, providing new directions for further research. ### Significance: - **Need for Further Research**: These findings will motivate more neutron scattering studies on CrI3 single crystals to further understand magnon-phonon interactions and the intrinsic nature of magnetic excitations. - **Understanding Topological Magnon Excitations**: This study contributes to a deeper understanding of topological magnon excitations and their impact on the thermal Hall effect.

Thermal Hall effect in a van der Waals ferromagnet CrI3

Magnon Transport and Thermal Properties of Confined Anisotropic CrI3

Antiferromagnetic-ferromagnetic homostructures with Dirac magnons in van der Waals magnet CrI$_3$

Giant Thermal Magnetoconductivity in CrCl_{3} and a General Model for Spin-Phonon Scattering

Coherent helicity-dependent spin-phonon oscillations in the ferromagnetic van der Waals crystal CrI3

Topological magnon gap engineering in van der Waals CrI$_3$ ferromagnets

Topological magnon insulator spin excitations in the two-dimensional ferromagnet CrBr 3

Quantum Anomalous Hall Effect by Coupling Heavy Atomic Layers with CrI_3

Theoretical Investigations on the Magneto-Raman Effect of CrI3

Anisotropic Magnon Transport in Van Der Waals Ferromagnetic Insulators

Theoretical investigations on the magneto-Raman effect of CrI 3

Distinct magneto-Raman signatures of spin-flip phase transitions in CrI3

Thermal Evolution of Dirac Magnons in the Honeycomb Ferromagnet CrBr$_3$

Topological Magnon Insulator Spin Excitations in the Two-Dimensional Ferromagnet CrBr3

Giant Effect of Spin-Lattice Coupling on the Thermal Transport in Two-Dimensional Ferromagnetic CrI3

Theoretical investigation of the magnetic properties of ferromagnetic CrI3 monolayer

Anomalous Hall effect of the quasi-two-dimensional weak itinerant ferromagnet Cr4.14Te8

Magnon-phonon interactions enhance the gap at the Dirac point in the spin-wave spectra of CrI$_3$ two-dimensional magnets

Spontaneous Crystal Thermal Hall Effect in Insulating Altermagnets

Electric Field-Modulated Magnetic Phase Transition in van der Waals CrI3 Bilayers

Topological Thermal Hall Effect Driven by Spin-Chirality Fluctuations in Frustrated Antiferromagnets