Abstract:We investigate the fragility of a topologically ordered state, namely, the ground state of a weakly Zeeman perturbed honeycomb Kitaev model to environment induced decoherence effects mimicked by random local projective measurements. Our findings show the nonabelian Ising topological order, as quantified by a tripartite mutual information (the topological entanglement entropy $\gamma$,) is resilient to such disturbances. Further, $\gamma$ is found to evolve smoothly from a topologically ordered state to a distribution of trivial states as a function of rate of measurement (temperature). We assess our model by contrasting it with the Toric Code limit of the Kitaev model, whose ground state has abelian $Z_2$ topological order, and which has garnered greater attention in the literature of fault-tolerant quantum computation. The findings reveal the topological order in the Toric Code limit collapses rapidly as opposed to our model where it can withstand higher measurement rates.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: to study the robustness of quantum states with Ising Topological Order (ITO) under local projection measurements. Specifically, the author explored the stability of the ground state of the honeycomb Kitaev model under weak magnetic field perturbations under the decoherence effect caused by the environment (simulated by random local projection measurements). The main purpose of the study is to evaluate the resistance of this topologically ordered state when facing local measurement interference, and to compare it with the Toric Code model with Z2 topological order, in order to reveal the behavioral differences of different models under the same conditions.
### Research Background
Topologically ordered states are a class of quantum states with peculiar properties, such as edge modes, anyon excitations, and long - range entanglement. These characteristics make topologically ordered states potentially useful in quantum information processing and computing. However, the sensitivity of these states to errors and decoherence may limit their practical applications. Therefore, understanding the impact of measurement - induced errors on these states is crucial for the development of robust quantum technologies.
### Research Methods
1. **Model Construction**:
- Consider a 2D isotropic Kitaev model containing Ising Topological Order. The Hamiltonian of this model is:
\[
\hat{H}=-\sum_{\langle ij \rangle \eta - link}\sigma^\eta_i\sigma^\eta_j + B\sum_{i,\eta}\sigma^\eta_i
\]
where the first term represents the ferromagnetic Kitaev interaction on the honeycomb lattice, and the second term represents the external magnetic field coupling in the (1, 1, 1) direction.
2. **Measurement Protocol**:
- Decoherence is introduced through periodic local projection measurements. For each measurement, a lattice point \(i\) is selected, and one of the following projection operators is applied:
\[
P_\pm=\frac{1\pm\sigma^z_i}{2}
\]
- The choice of the projection operator is based on the comparison between the expected value of the transient state at the measurement moment and a random number:
\[
P_i = pP_++(1 - p)P_-
\]
where the choice of \(p\) depends on the comparison result between \(\langle\sigma^z_i\rangle\) and a random number \(c\) uniformly drawn from the interval \((-1, 1)\).
3. **Numerical Simulation**:
- Use the exact diagonalization method to obtain the ground state of the system, and simulate the measurement process through non - unitary random evolution.
- Calculate the three - body mutual information (i.e., the topological entanglement entropy \(\gamma\)) under different measurement rates, and analyze its time evolution and saturation value.
### Main Findings
1. **Evolution of Topological Entanglement Entropy**:
- As the measurement rate increases, the topological entanglement entropy \(\gamma\) gradually decreases, but the decay rate is slow.
- At a low measurement rate, unitary evolution has enough time to reconstruct entanglement, enabling the system to partially recover the topologically ordered state.
2. **Non - equilibrium Steady State (NESS)**:
- At different measurement rates, the system eventually reaches a non - equilibrium steady state, in which the three - body mutual information tends to be stable.
- Compared with the Toric Code model, the topological order in the Kitaev model is more resistant to local measurements. Even at a high measurement rate, the decrease in \(\gamma\) is relatively slow.
3. **Energy Distribution and Magnetization Distribution**:
- At a high measurement rate, the energy distribution of the system has multiple peaks, indicating that the system is in a superposition state of multiple energy levels.
- The magnetization distribution shows that even at a high measurement rate, the system still retains the characteristics of the initial topologically ordered state, manifested as double - magnon peaks in the magnetization distribution.
### Conclusion
This study reveals the robustness of the Kitaev model with Ising Topological Order under local projection measurements, especially that it can still maintain a certain topologically ordered state at a high measurement rate. In comparison, the Z2 topological order in the Toric Code model is more sensitive to local measurements and is prone to rapid collapse. These findings are important for understanding...