Modulational instability of nonuniformly damped, broad-banded waves: applications to waves in sea-ice

Raphael Stuhlmeier,Conor Heffernan,Alberto Alberello,Emilian Părău
2024-03-12
Abstract:This paper sets out to explore the modulational (or Benjamin-Feir) instability of a monochromatic wave propagating in the presence of damping such as that induced by sea-ice on the ocean surface. The fundamental wave motion is modelled using the spatial Zakharov equation, to which either uniform or non-uniform (frequency dependent) damping is added. By means of mode truncation the spatial analogue of the classical Benjamin-Feir instability can be studied analytically using dynamical systems techniques. The formulation readily yields the free surface envelope, giving insight into the physical implications of damping on the modulational instability. The evolution of an initially unstable mode is also studied numerically by integrating the damped, spatial Zakharov equation, in order to complement the analytical theory. This sheds light on the effects of damping on spectral broadening arising from this instability.
Fluid Dynamics,Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to explore the influence of inhomogeneous damping on the modulation instability (or Benjamin - Feir instability) of broadband waves in the presence of sea ice. Specifically, the paper studies the behavior of modulation instability when a monochromatic wave propagates on the ocean surface under damping conditions. The main focuses include: 1. **Analysis of modulation instability**: - Use the spatial Zakharov equation to model the basic wave motion and add a uniform or inhomogeneous (frequency - dependent) damping term. - Analyze the spatial analogy of modulation instability using dynamical system techniques through the mode - truncation method. 2. **Physical influence of damping on modulation instability**: - Derive the free - surface envelope by analytical methods to reveal the influence of damping on the physical meaning of modulation instability. - Numerically simulate the damped spatial Zakharov equation to study the evolution of the initially unstable mode and further clarify the influence of damping on spectral broadening. 3. **Wave propagation in sea ice**: - Pay special attention to the inhomogeneous damping caused by sea ice and its unique influence on wave propagation and modulation instability due to its frequency - dependent characteristics. ### Specific problem description - **Background of modulation instability**: - Water waves are usually persistent, but it is very difficult to generate monochromatic waves in the laboratory and in nature because monochromatic waves are very sensitive to small perturbations and are prone to modulation instability. - Benjamin and Feir proved that monochromatic waves are unstable to small perturbations within a certain parameter range, and energy will be transferred from one Fourier mode to adjacent modes, forming the so - called degenerate four - wave interaction. - **Role of damping**: - Although water waves are unstable during propagation, surfers can catch swells generated by storms thousands of kilometers away, indicating that damping can stabilize modulation instability in some cases. - The presence of sea ice leads to inhomogeneous damping, and the specific influence of this damping on wave propagation and modulation instability is the focus of this paper. - **Research methods**: - Use the spatial Zakharov equation as a starting point to derive the spatial nonlinear Schrödinger equation containing a damping term. - Analyze the dynamical systems under uniform and inhomogeneous damping to explore wave evolution and stability changes under different damping conditions. ### Main contributions - **Theoretical derivation**: - Propose an analytical solution method for the spatial Zakharov equation containing a damping term, revealing the influence mechanism of damping on modulation instability. - Derive the spatial nonlinear Schrödinger equation, providing a theoretical basis for further research. - **Numerical simulation**: - Verify the correctness of the theoretical derivation through numerical simulation and show the specific behavior of wave evolution under different damping conditions. - Study the influence of inhomogeneous damping on spectral broadening, providing a new perspective for understanding wave propagation in sea ice. ### Conclusions - **Stabilizing effect of damping on modulation instability**: - Uniform damping can stabilize modulation instability to a certain extent, making the initially unstable wave tend to be stable after propagating a certain distance. - The influence of inhomogeneous damping on modulation instability is more complex and may lead to an imbalance in side - band energy, affecting wave propagation and evolution. - **Future research directions**: - Further explore the long - term behavior of wave propagation under different damping conditions. - Study the similar influence of damping on modulation instability in other physical environments. Through these studies, the paper provides important theoretical and experimental bases for understanding wave propagation and modulation instability in sea ice.