FFAD: A Novel Metric for Assessing Generated Time Series Data Utilizing Fourier Transform and Auto-encoder

Yang Chen,Dustin J. Kempton,Rafal A. Angryk
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2403.06576
2024-03-11
Abstract:The success of deep learning-based generative models in producing realistic images, videos, and audios has led to a crucial consideration: how to effectively assess the quality of synthetic samples. While the Fréchet Inception Distance (FID) serves as the standard metric for evaluating generative models in image synthesis, a comparable metric for time series data is notably absent. This gap in assessment capabilities stems from the absence of a widely accepted feature vector extractor pre-trained on benchmark time series datasets. In addressing these challenges related to assessing the quality of time series, particularly in the context of Fréchet Distance, this work proposes a novel solution leveraging the Fourier transform and Auto-encoder, termed the Fréchet Fourier-transform Auto-encoder Distance (FFAD). Through our experimental results, we showcase the potential of FFAD for effectively distinguishing samples from different classes. This novel metric emerges as a fundamental tool for the evaluation of generative time series data, contributing to the ongoing efforts of enhancing assessment methodologies in the realm of deep learning-based generative models.
Machine Learning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to effectively evaluate the quality of generated time - series data. Specifically, although the Fréchet Inception Distance (FID) has become the standard metric for evaluating image - generation models, in the field of time - series data, there is still a lack of a widely - accepted feature - vector extractor to evaluate the quality of generated samples. Therefore, the authors propose a new metric - Fréchet Fourier - transform Auto - encoder Distance (FFAD) - to fill this gap. ### Specific Background and Challenges of the Problem 1. **Challenges in Evaluating Generated Time - Series Data**: - Time - series data has complex structures and dynamic characteristics, and it is difficult to evaluate its quality through simple visual inspection. - The lack of a standardized evaluation metric similar to FID makes it difficult to evaluate the quality of generated time - series data. 2. **Limitations of Existing Methods**: - The Fréchet Inception Distance (FID) is currently the standard metric for evaluating image - generation models, but it is not applicable to time - series data because there is no widely - accepted pre - trained model that can be used to extract feature vectors of time - series data. - Other evaluation methods may not be able to effectively capture the unique properties of time - series data. ### Proposed Solution To address the above challenges, the authors propose the Fréchet Fourier - transform Auto - encoder Distance (FFAD). FFAD combines two techniques, Fourier - transform and Auto - encoder, aiming to provide an effective method for evaluating the quality of generated time - series data. The specific steps are as follows: 1. **Fourier - transform**: - Use the Fourier - transform to convert time - series data from the time domain to the frequency domain, thereby ensuring that all time - series data have a consistent input length and retain key features. - Select an appropriate number of frequency components to achieve a standardized representation and reduce the impact of changes in the length of time - series data. 2. **Auto - encoder**: - Train a general - purpose Auto - encoder model to compress and reconstruct time - series data. - Use the trained Encoder part to generate a low - dimensional representation to evaluate the differences between different categories. 3. **FFAD Calculation**: - Based on the generated low - dimensional representation, calculate the FFAD score to measure the similarity between different categories or between real and synthetic samples. ### Core Formula of FFAD The formula for calculating the FFAD score is: \[ \text{FFAD Score} = ||\mu_{Y_{\text{pos}}} - \mu_{Y_{\text{neg}}}||^2 + \text{Tr}(\Sigma_{Y_{\text{pos}}} + \Sigma_{Y_{\text{neg}}} - 2\sqrt{\Sigma_{Y_{\text{pos}}}\Sigma_{Y_{\text{neg}}}}) \] where: - \( Y_{\text{pos}} \) and \( Y_{\text{neg}} \) are the encoded representations of positive - class and negative - class samples respectively. - \( \mu_{Y_{\text{pos}}} \) and \( \mu_{Y_{\text{neg}}} \) are the mean vectors of the encoded representations of positive - class and negative - class samples respectively. - \( \Sigma_{Y_{\text{pos}}} \) and \( \Sigma_{Y_{\text{neg}}} \) are the covariance matrices of the encoded representations of positive - class and negative - class samples respectively. - \( \text{Tr}(.) \) represents the trace of a matrix. ### Experimental Verification The authors experimentally verified the effectiveness of FFAD and demonstrated its potential in distinguishing samples of different categories. FFAD can not only evaluate the realism of generated samples, but also check whether the generated samples are...