On the mutual exclusiveness of time and position in quantum physics and the corresponding uncertainty relation for free falling particles

Mathieu Beau,Lionel Martellini
2024-03-10
Abstract:The uncertainty principle is one of the characteristic properties of quantum theory, where it signals the incompatibility of two types of measurements. In this paper, we argue that measurements of time-of-arrival $T_x$ at position $x$ and position $X_t$ at time $t$ are mutually exclusive for a quantum system, each providing complementary information about the state of that system. For a quantum particle of mass $m$ falling in a uniform gravitational field $g$, we show that the corresponding uncertainty relation can be expressed as $\Delta T_x \Delta X_t \geq \frac{\hbar}{2mg}$. This uncertainty relationship can be taken as evidence of the presence of a form of epistemic incompatibility in the sense that preparing the initial state of the system so as to decrease the measured position uncertainty will lead to an increase in the measured time-of-arrival uncertainty. These findings can be empirically tested in the context of ongoing or forthcoming experiments on measurements of time-of-arrival for free-falling quantum particles.
Quantum Physics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Mathematical Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper discusses the complementarity between time and position in quantum physics and the uncertainty relation related to the free-falling particle. The author points out that in a quantum system, time-of-arrival (TOA) and position measurements are mutually exclusive, with each measurement providing different information about the system's state. For a quantum particle of mass m falling in a uniform gravitational field g, the corresponding uncertainty relation can be expressed as ∆Tx∆Xt≥ℏ2mg. This means that reducing the initial position uncertainty will increase the measurement uncertainty of time-of-arrival. These findings can be verified through ongoing or upcoming experiments on time-of-arrival measurement of free-falling quantum particles. The article also highlights the blind spot of time-of-arrival problem in the description of physical phenomena in quantum theory, especially in the interpretation of quantum gravity theory and experiments on free-falling quantum atoms. Although there have been studies on time measurements of free-falling Gaussian systems, there is still no consensus on a formal method for analyzing time-of-arrival. Furthermore, the author proposes that this new type of uncertainty relation between time and position measurements indicates a form of intellectual incompatibility between them. They demonstrate through the analysis of different experimental protocols for measuring these two quantities that the intellectual nature of position and time measurements is significantly different at the experimental level, and it is not possible to simultaneously improve the accuracy of both. The paper presents the uncertainty relation between TOA and position of free-falling particles and confirms numerically that ℏ2mg serves as a lower bound for all cases. In addition, they discuss the relationship between this time/position uncertainty relation and the standard time/energy uncertainty relation, which is related to the dispersion of time-of-arrival measurements at specific positions and the energy dispersion of quantum systems. In summary, the paper aims to address the problem of understanding and measuring time-of-arrival in quantum theory, proposes a new principle of uncertainty, and discusses the experimental verification and potential applications of this principle, such as its impact on quantum metrology and quantum gravity theory.