Quantum-Based Salp Swarm Algorithm Driven Design Optimization of Savonius Wind Turbine-Cylindrical Deflector System

Paras Singh,Vishal Jaiswal,Subhrajit Roy,Aryan Tyagi,Gaurav Kumar,Raj Kumar Singh
2024-03-08
Abstract:Savonius turbines, prominent in small-scale wind turbine applications operating under low-speed conditions, encounter limitations due to opposing torque on the returning blade, impeding high efficiency. A viable solution involves mitigating this retarding torque by directing incoming airflow through a cylindrical deflector. However, such flow control is highly contingent upon the location and size of the cylindrical deflector, and its angular velocity. This study introduces a novel design optimization framework tailored for enhancing the turbine-deflector system's performance. Leveraging surrogate models for computational efficiency, six different models were assessed, with Kriging selected for subsequent analysis based on its superior performance at approximating the relation between design parameters and objective function. The training data for the surrogate model and the flow field data around the system were obtained through Unsteady Reynolds-Averaged Navier Stokes (URANS) simulations using a sliding mesh technique. An in-house code for the Quantum-based Salp Swarm Optimization (QSSO) algorithm was then employed to obtain design parameters corresponding to the peak power coefficient (Cp) for the stationary deflector-turbine system. Additionally, the QSSO algorithm was quantitatively compared with nine other competing algorithms. The optimized stationary deflector-turbine system showed an improvement of 26.94% in Cp at Tip Speed Ratio (TSR) of 0.9 compared to the baseline case. Further investigation into the effect of deflector rotational velocity ($\omega_d$) revealed significant improvements: 40.98% and 11.33% enhancement at $\omega_d$ = 3 rad/s, and 51.23% and 19.42% at $\omega_d$ = 40 rad/s, compared to configurations without a deflector and with the optimized stationary deflector, respectively at a TSR of 0.9.
Fluid Dynamics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to improve the efficiency of Savonius wind turbines under low - speed conditions. Specifically, the paper optimizes the design of the Savonius wind turbine system by introducing a cylindrical deflector to reduce the reverse torque on the return blade, thereby enhancing the overall performance. However, the effect of this flow control is highly dependent on the position, size, and angular velocity of the cylindrical deflector. Therefore, the main objective of the study is to develop a new design - optimization framework, using surrogate models and the Quantum - based Salp Swarm Optimization (QSSO), to find the optimal combination of design parameters and maximize the power coefficient \(C_p\) of the system. ### Main contributions of the paper 1. **Data collection and surrogate model training**: Data is collected through Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations and surrogate models are trained. 2. **Comparison of different surrogate models**: Six different surrogate models are evaluated, and the Kriging - based model is selected because it performs best in approximating the relationship between design parameters and the objective function. 3. **Implementation of the Quantum - based Salp Swarm Optimization algorithm**: Using self - written QSSO algorithm code, the design parameters that maximize the power coefficient \(C_p\) of the fixed deflector - turbine system are determined. 4. **Comparison with other meta - heuristic algorithms**: The QSSO algorithm is quantitatively compared with nine other competing algorithms. 5. **Determination of the optimal rotation speed**: The influence of the deflector rotation speed on the system performance is studied, and the optimal rotation speed is found, thereby achieving the maximum power output of the system. ### Main findings - The optimized fixed deflector - turbine system has a 26.94% increase in the power coefficient \(C_p\) at a tip - speed ratio (TSR) of 0.9. - When the rotation speed of the deflector \(\omega_d\) is 3 rad/s and 40 rad/s respectively, the power coefficient \(C_p\) is increased by 40.98% and 51.23% respectively compared to the configurations without a deflector and the optimized fixed deflector. ### Conclusion This study proposes a robust optimization framework, which not only improves the performance of Savonius wind turbines, but also demonstrates the potential of surrogate modeling and advanced optimization algorithms in solving aerodynamic challenges in wind turbine design. The application scope of this framework is not limited to this study, but can also be used for multi - parameter optimization in the energy field.