Abstract:Mathematical and simulation models are often used to predict the spread of a disease and estimate the impact of public health interventions, and many such models have been developed and used during the COVID-19 pandemic. This paper describes a study that systematically compared models for a university community, which has a much smaller but more connected population than a state or nation. We developed a stochastic agent-based model, a deterministic compartment model, and a model based on ordinary differential equations. All three models represented the disease progression with the same susceptible-exposed-infectious-recovered (SEIR) model. We created a baseline scenario for a population of 14,000 students and faculty and eleven other scenarios for combinations of interventions such as regular testing, contact tracing, quarantine, isolation, moving courses online, mask wearing, improving ventilation, and vaccination. We used parameter values from other epidemiological studies and incorporated data about COVID-19 testing in College Park, Maryland, but the study was designed to compare modeling approaches to each other using a synthetic population. For each scenario we used the models to estimate the number of persons who become infected over a semester of 119 days. We evaluated the models by comparing their predictions and evaluating their parsimony and computational effort. The agent-based model (ABM) and the deterministic compartment model (DCM) had similar results with cyclic flow of persons to and from quarantine, but the model based on ordinary differential equations failed to capture these dynamics. The ABM's computation time was much greater than the other two models' computation time. The DCM captured some of the dynamics that were present in the ABM's predictions and, like those from the ABM, clearly showed the importance of testing and moving classes on-line.

The importance of the incubation time distribution in compartmental epidemiological models

A new formulation of compartmental epidemic modelling for arbitrary distributions of incubation and removal times

Compartmental Model for Epidemics with Contact Tracing and Isolation under Arbitrary Degree Distribution

Intervention Strategies for Epidemics: Does Ignoring Time Delay Lead to Incorrect Predictions?

Modeling correlated uncertainties in stochastic compartmental models

Toward a comprehensive system for constructing compartmental epidemic models

Dynamics of a Tuberculosis Outbreak Model in a Multi-scale Environment

Simulation of deterministic compartmental models for infectious diseases dynamics

The Poisson algorithm: a simple method to simulate stochastic epidemic models with generally distributed residence times

Epidemic modelling requires knowledge of the social network

Epidemic Models with Random Infectious Period

Stochastic compartmental models of COVID-19 pandemic must have temporally correlated uncertainties

Ebola impact and quarantine in a network model

Origin of Multiple Infection Waves in a Pandemic: Effects of Inherent Susceptibility and External Infectivity Distributions

Modeling the Spread of COVID-19 in University Communities

A nonstandard numerical scheme for a novel SECIR integro-differential equation-based model allowing nonexponentially distributed stay times

Relatedness of the Incidence Decay with Exponential Adjustment (IDEA) Model, "Farr's Law" and Compartmental Difference Equation SIR Models

Limited data on infectious disease distribution exposes ambiguity in epidemic modeling choices

Fractional and fractal extensions of epidemiological models

Products of Compartmental Models in Epidemiology

Modelling preventive measures and their effect on generation times in emerging epidemics