Strengthening nuclear symmetry energy constraints using multiple resonant shattering flares of neutron stars with realistic mass uncertainties

Duncan Neill,David Tsang,William G. Newton

2024-03-06

Abstract:With current and planned gravitational-wave (GW) observing runs, coincident multimessenger timing of Resonant Shattering Flares (RSFs) and GWs may soon allow for neutron star (NS) asteroseismology to be used to constrain the nuclear symmetry energy, an important property of fundamental nuclear physics that influences the composition and equation of state of NSs. In this work we examine the effects of combining multiple RSF detections on these symmetry energy constraints, and consider how realistic uncertainties in the masses of the progenitor NSs may weaken them. We show that the detection of subsequent multimessenger events has the potential to substantially improve constraints beyond those obtained from the first, and that this improvement is insensitive to the mass of the NSs which produce the RSFs and its uncertainty. This sets these asteroseismic constraints apart from bulk NS properties such as radius, for which the NS mass is highly important, meaning that any multimessenger RSF and GW events can equally improve our knowledge of fundamental physics.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,Nuclear Experiment

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses the use of Resonant Shattering Flares (RSFs) and Gravitational Waves (GWs) as multiple messengers to enhance constraints on nuclear symmetry energy. Nuclear symmetry energy is an important concept in nuclear physics that affects the composition and equation of state of neutron stars (NSs). By studying the internal structure of neutron stars through astroseismology, particularly by detecting RSFs and GWs coincidentally, the nuclear symmetry energy can be constrained.

The main findings of the paper include:
1. The detection of multiple RSF events can significantly improve constraints on nuclear symmetry energy, independent of the mass of the neutron stars that produce the RSFs.
2. These astroseismological constraints on nuclear symmetry energy are less dependent on the mass of neutron stars compared to other factors, suggesting that any multi-messenger RSF and GW event can enhance our understanding of fundamental physics.

The research methods include:
1. Using a meta-model of NSs to generate a range of nuclear physics parameters and study the relationship between neutron star mass and i-mode frequency.
2. Constructing artificial samples of binary neutron stars or black hole-neutron star mergers to simulate gravitational wave analysis and obtain uncertainties in neutron star mass.
3. Investigating how multiple multi-messenger events can improve constraints on nuclear symmetry energy by reducing statistical uncertainties in data and studying mass-frequency relationships.

The paper concludes that although the current number of observations is limited, future GW observations combined with data from multiple RSF and GW events could provide stronger constraints on nuclear symmetry energy, thereby deepening our understanding of nuclear physics and the internal structure of neutron stars.