Bounding speedup of quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo

Alev Orfi,Dries Sels
2024-03-06
Abstract:Sampling tasks are a natural class of problems for quantum computers due to the probabilistic nature of the Born rule. Sampling from useful distributions on noisy quantum hardware remains a challenging problem. A recent paper [Layden, D. et al. Nature 619, 282-287 (2023)] proposed a quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm where moves are generated by a quantum device and accepted or rejected by a classical algorithm. While this procedure is robust to noise and control imperfections, its potential for quantum advantage is unclear. Here we show that there is no speedup over classical sampling on a worst-case unstructured sampling problem. We present an upper bound to the Markov gap that rules out a speedup for any unital quantum proposal.
Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper investigates whether the quantum-enhanced Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithm can provide acceleration in solving the worst-case unstructured sampling problem. The researchers focus on a system consisting of N discrete spin variables and aim to sample from the Boltzmann distribution of the classical Hamiltonian. They analyze a quantum proposal generated by a quantum device and accepted or rejected by a classical algorithm in the quantum-enhanced MCMC algorithm. The paper points out that although this algorithm performs robustly under noise and imperfect control, there is no formal proof of its advantage over classical methods. The authors present a simple example where the quantum-enhanced MCMC algorithm fails to provide acceleration in the worst-case unstructured problem compared to classical sampling. They demonstrate through the analysis of the upper bound of the Markov chain gap that there is no acceleration for any unit quantum proposal. The paper also compares two different quantum mixing strategies, namely Grover mixing and transverse field mixing. Through precise spectral gap calculations, they find that regardless of the chosen strategy, the quantum algorithm's speed improvement is not significant compared to random or local classical proposal strategies, especially for large system size or different systems. This indicates that the current quantum proposal strategies do not provide significant advantages over classical methods for certain problems. In conclusion, this paper aims to address the potential acceleration effects of the quantum-enhanced MCMC algorithm in practical applications. Through theoretical analysis and specific examples of unstructured sampling tasks, it shows that this quantum algorithm may not achieve faster speeds than classical methods.