Impact of unmodeled eccentricity on the tidal deformability measurement and implications for gravitational wave physics inference

Poulami Dutta Roy,Pankaj Saini

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.110.024002

2024-07-07

Abstract:With the expected large number of binary neutron star (BNS) observations through gravitational waves (GWs), third-generation GW detectors, Cosmic Explorer (CE) and Einstein Telescope (ET), will be able to constrain the tidal deformability, and hence the equation of state (EoS) of neutron star (NS) with exquisite precision. A subset of the detected BNS systems can retain residual eccentricity in the detector frequency band. We study the systematic errors due to unmodeled eccentricity in the tidal deformability measurement and its implications for NS EoS and redshift measurement via the Love siren method. We find that the systematic errors in the tidal deformability parameter exceed the statistical errors at an eccentricity of $\sim 10^{-3}$ ($\sim 3\times 10^{-4}$) at $10$Hz reference GW frequency for CE (ET). We show that these biases on tidal deformability parameter can significantly bias the NS EoS inference. Furthermore, the error on tidal deformability propagates to the source frame NS mass, which in turn biases the redshift inference. For CE, the redshift inference is significantly biased at an eccentricity of $\sim 10^{-3}$ (at a reference frequency of $10$Hz). We also study the implications of biased tidal deformability in testing the Kerr nature of black holes. Systematic error on the tidal deformability parameter leads to a non-zero value of tidal deformability for binary black holes, indicating a false deviation from the Kerr nature. Finally, we show that including eccentricity in the waveform model increases the statistical errors in tidal deformability measurement by a factor of $\lesssim 2$. Our study, therefore, highlights the importance of using accurate eccentric waveform models for GW parameter inference.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to explore the influence of unmodeled orbital eccentricity on the measurement of tidal deformation parameters in double - neutron - star systems (BNS) and its significance for gravitational - wave physics inferences. Specifically, the research focuses on:

1. **Systematic errors in tidal deformation parameter measurement**:
- Investigate the systematic errors of unmodeled orbital eccentricity in tidal deformation parameter measurement and analyze the impact of these errors on the inference of the neutron - star equation of state (EoS).
- Explore how these systematic errors propagate to the neutron - star mass in the source frame and further affect redshift measurement.

2. **Deviations in redshift measurement**:
- Through the "Love siren" method, study how the deviation of tidal deformation parameters affects redshift measurement, especially when using third - generation gravitational - wave detectors such as Cosmic Explorer and Einstein Telescope.

3. **Tests of Kerr black - hole properties**:
- Analyze how the deviation of tidal deformation parameters leads to false non - Kerr properties in binary black - hole systems.

### Main findings

- **Systematic errors exceed statistical errors**:
- For Cosmic Explorer (CE), when the initial eccentricity \( e_0\sim10^{- 3}\), the systematic error of the tidal deformation parameter exceeds the statistical error.
- For Einstein Telescope (ET), this threshold is lower, approximately \( e_0\sim3\times10^{-4}\).

- **Deviation in EoS inference**:
- Systematic errors in tidal deformation parameters can lead to deviations in the inference of the neutron - star equation of state (EoS), thus affecting the understanding of the internal structure of neutron stars.

- **Deviation in redshift measurement**:
- Through the "Love siren" method, the deviation of tidal deformation parameters can propagate to the neutron - star mass in the source frame, and then lead to the deviation of redshift measurement. For CE, when the initial eccentricity \( e_0\sim10^{-3}\), the redshift measurement has a significant deviation.

- **False deviation from Kerr properties**:
- Systematic errors in tidal deformation parameters can cause non - zero values in the tidal deformation parameters of binary black - hole systems, which may be misinterpreted as a deviation from Kerr properties.

### Conclusion

This research emphasizes the importance of using accurate eccentric waveform models for parameter inference in third - generation gravitational - wave detectors. Unmodeled orbital eccentricity may introduce significant systematic errors, which are particularly evident in high - signal - to - noise - ratio events and may lead to incorrect inferences of the neutron - star equation of state, redshift measurement, and Kerr - property tests. Therefore, in order to obtain more accurate physical results, orbital eccentricity needs to be considered in the waveform model.