How small droplets form in turbulent multiphase flows

Marco Crialesi-Esposito,Guido Boffetta,Luca Brandt,Sergio Chibbaro,Stefano Musacchio
2024-02-29
Abstract:The formation of small droplets and bubbles in turbulent flows is a crucial process in geophysics and engineering, whose underlying physical mechanism remains a puzzle. In this letter, we address this problem by means of high-resolution numerical simulations, comparing a realistic multiphase configuration with a numerical experiment in which we attenuate the presence of strong velocity gradients either across the whole mixture or in the disperse phase only. Our results show unambiguously that the formation of small droplets is governed by the internal dynamics which occur during the break-up of large drops and that the high vorticity and the extreme dissipation associated to these events are the consequence and not the cause of the breakup.
Fluid Dynamics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to solve the problem of the formation mechanism of tiny droplets in turbulent multiphase flow. Specifically, the author explored the formation process of small droplets in turbulence through high - resolution numerical simulations, especially whether the formation of these droplets is caused by high vorticity and extreme dissipation events or by internal dynamic processes. ### Background of the paper In many industrial and environmental processes, the break - up dynamics of droplets and bubbles is a fundamental issue. Due to the complex turbulent environment, droplets usually have a wide size distribution. For some applications, the diameter of the smallest droplets or bubbles is particularly important, such as the dissolution of air bubbles in the ocean or the transport of oil droplets in the ocean after an oil spill. ### Key issues The paper mainly explored the following two possible mechanisms: 1. **Extreme turbulent events**: Local extreme turbulent events lead to a decrease in the Kolmogorov - Hinze (KH) scale, thereby causing droplet break - up. 2. **Capillary dynamics**: The filaments formed during the deformation of droplets further split through capillary instability, ultimately producing small droplets. ### Research methods The author controlled small - scale dynamics through high - resolution numerical simulations and suppressed high - vorticity regions by adding a penalty term to the momentum equation. The specific methods are as follows: - **Single - phase flow (SP)**: As a reference benchmark. - **Multiphase flow (MP)**: Flow containing droplets. - **Full - region penalty (MPp)**: Suppress high vorticity in the entire flow field. - **Penalty within the dispersed phase (MPp, i)**: Suppress high vorticity only within the droplets. ### Main results 1. **Visual comparison**: It can be seen from Figure 2 that suppressing the local gradient partially suppresses the formation of small droplets but retains the large - scale flow structure. 2. **Statistical analysis**: - **Probability density function (PDF) of vorticity and dissipation**: Figure 3 shows that the PDF tails of vorticity and dissipation in multiphase flow are longer than those in single - phase flow, indicating that the interface increases intermittency. The penalty term significantly affects the vorticity PDF at the vorticity threshold. - **PDF of velocity increment**: Figure 4 shows that the multiphase flow is more intermittent without penalty. When the penalty is applied to the entire fluid, the distribution becomes similar to a Gaussian distribution; while when the penalty is only applied within the dispersed phase, the distribution changes less. 3. **Droplet size distribution**: Figure 5 shows that the penalty term has a small impact on large droplets but significantly reduces the number of small droplets. In particular, the number of small droplets in MPp flow is approximately 60% of that in MP flow. ### Conclusion The main conclusion of the paper is that the formation of small droplets is mainly dominated by internal dynamic processes, especially capillary instability. High vorticity and extreme dissipation events are the results rather than the causes of droplet break - up. This finding helps to simplify the research on the formation of small droplets, and in the future, more attention can be focused on the deformation state of droplets and their internal dynamics.