Shorts on the Rise: Assessing the Effects of YouTube Shorts on Long-Form Video Content

Prajit T. Rajendran,Kevin Creusy,Vivien Garnes

2024-04-08

Abstract:Short form content has permeated into the video creator space over the past few years, led by industry leading products such as TikTok, YouTube Shorts and Instagram Reels. YouTube in particular was previously synonymous with being the main hub for long form video content consumption. The monetization of long form videos was easier as it allowed multiple advertisement placements during the course of the video. This model also facilitated thematic brand partnerships. However, since the introduction of short form content, creators have found it more difficult to generate revenue as advertisement placements have decreased. This leads to a unique situation where people are spending more time watching shorter videos, and yet they generate less revenue for the creators. In this paper, we perform a study of 250 creators with significant audiences to see if the introduction of short form content has affected the view counts and engagement of long form content. Our findings reveal a noteworthy trend: since the advent of short-form content, there has been a significant decrease in both view counts and engagement in long-form videos on these channels.

Social and Information Networks,Multimedia

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to explore the impact of short videos (such as YouTube Shorts) on long video content. Specifically, the research focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Interaction between Short Videos and Long Videos**:
- Does the introduction of short videos affect the view counts and user engagement of long videos?
- Differences in user consumption behavior between short videos and long videos.

2. **Creator Adaptation Strategies**:
- How do different types of creators adapt to the rise of short videos?
- The impact of creator categories (such as lifestyle, entertainment, technology, etc.) on the adoption of short videos.

3. **Economic Impact**:
- The income challenges faced by long video creators after the rise of short videos.
- The impact of short videos on advertising effectiveness and brand attitudes.

By analyzing data from 250 creators with significant audiences, the paper reveals a significant downward trend in view counts and user engagement for long video content following the rise of short videos. It further explores the specific impacts under different creator categories and subscriber scales. The research results indicate that short videos generally outperform long videos in terms of view counts and likes, but long videos perform better in terms of the number of comments. Additionally, for top creators with more than 5 million subscribers, the introduction of short videos has a more significant impact on the view counts of their long video content. These findings present new challenges to the creator community, necessitating the exploration of new monetization mechanisms to adapt to the changing video consumption patterns.