A Tampering Risk of Fiber-Based Frequency Synchronization Networks and Its Countermeasures

Hongfei Dai,Yufeng Chen,Wenlin Li,Fangmin Wang,Guan Wang,Zhongwang Pang,Bo Wang
2024-02-28
Abstract:Fiber optic networks are used worldwide and have been regarded as excellent media for transmitting time-frequency (TF) signals. In the past decades, fiber-based TF synchronization techniques have been extensively studied. Instruments based on these techniques have been successfully applied. With the increasing application of TF synchronization instruments, their security has become an important issue. Unfortunately, the security risks of fiber-based frequency synchronization (FbFS) instruments have been overlooked. This paper proposes a frequency tampering method called "frequency lens". On a 200 km fiber link, we demonstrate a frequency tampering scenario using a frequency lens-enabled frequency tampering module (FTM). On the user side, the frequency value of the recovered 100 MHz signal can be stealthily altered within a range of 100 MHz-100 Hz to 100 MHz+100 Hz, while the frequency dissemination stability of the system remains normal. Related to this tampering risk, potential hazards in three different application scenarios, which rely on precise frequency references, are analyzed. Two countermeasures are also proposed to solve this tampering risk.
Instrumentation and Detectors
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper focuses on the security issues of fiber optic frequency synchronization networks. The author proposes a frequency tampering method called "frequency lens", which can secretly tamper with the 100 MHz signal frequency on a 200 km fiber optic link without compromising system stability. The tampering range can reach ±100 Hz. This tampering is difficult to detect at the user end because it maintains the relative stability of frequency distribution while bypassing phase-locked state monitoring. The paper also analyzes the risks that this frequency tampering may bring, especially in application scenarios such as timekeeping, metrology, navigation, and radio astronomy that rely on precise frequency references. Although these applications can function normally, they may result in errors or biases. For example, in a timekeeping network, frequency tampering can cause slight changes in time intervals; in metrology, frequency tampering may affect the accuracy of length units; in radio astronomy, frequency differences can lead to decreased observation accuracy. To address these risks, the paper proposes two prevention measures. One is to combine fiber vibration detection for link patrols to detect and quickly locate intrusions. The other is to build a more robust fiber optic frequency synchronization network by setting multiple connection paths to ensure timely detection when a single frequency reference encounters problems. In summary, this paper reveals the potential security vulnerabilities in fiber optic frequency synchronization systems and proposes corresponding countermeasures, aiming to raise awareness and future research on this security issue.