Integrating Dark Pattern Taxonomies

Frank Lewis,Julita Vassileva

2024-02-27

Abstract:The problem of ``Dark Patterns" in user interface/user experience (UI/UX) design has proven a difficult issue to tackle. Malicious and explotitative design has expanded to multiple domains in the past 10 years and which has in turn led to multiple taxonomies attempting to describe them. While these taxonomies holds their own merit, and constitute unique contributions to the literature, their usefulness as separate entities is limited. We believe that in order to make meaningful progress in regulating malicious interface design, we must first form a globally harmonized system (GHS) for the classification and labeling of Dark Patterns. By leaning on network analysis tools and methods, this paper synthesizes existing taxonomies and their elements through as a directed graph. In doing so, the interconnectedness of Dark patterns can be more clearly revealed via community (cluster) detection. Ultimately, we hope that this work can serve as the inspiration for the creation of a glyph-based GHS for the classification of Dark Patterns.

Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to solve the problem of "Dark Patterns" in user interface/user experience (UI/UX) design. Specifically, the author believes that there are currently multiple classification systems (i.e., taxonomies) for describing dark patterns, but these classification systems are fragmented and lack unity, resulting in limited effectiveness in practical applications.

In order to effectively regulate malicious interface designs and protect users, the author proposes the need to establish a globally unified classification and labeling system (similar to the Globally Harmonized System of Classification and Labelling of Chemicals, GHS). By integrating existing dark - pattern taxonomies and using network analysis tools to reveal the relationships between dark patterns, the author hopes to ultimately create a symbol - based globally unified system (GHS) for classifying and labeling dark patterns.

#### Main objectives:
1. **Integrate existing taxonomies**: Integrate existing dark - pattern taxonomies into a unified system through network analysis methods.
2. **Reveal the relationships between dark patterns**: Use community detection techniques to reveal the internal connections between dark patterns.
3. **Construct a globally unified system**: Create a classification and labeling system for dark patterns similar to the GHS for chemicals to regulate and warn users.

#### Specific problems to be solved:
- **Fragmentation of classification systems**: Currently, there are multiple independent dark - pattern classification systems that lack unified standards.
- **Difficulties in regulation**: Due to the lack of a unified classification and labeling system, it is difficult to effectively regulate and standardize the design of dark patterns.
- **Lack of user awareness**: Many users are not aware of the existence of dark patterns and their potential harm, and it is necessary to raise user awareness through standardized warning labels.

Through the above measures, the author hopes to make substantial progress in regulation, education, and user protection, and reduce the exploitation and misguidance of users by dark patterns.