Abstract:It is now established that the increase in atmospheric CO 2 is likely to cause a weakening, or perhaps a collapse, of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC). To investigate the mechanisms of this response in CMIP5 models, Levang and Schmitt (2020) have estimated the geostrophic streamfunction in these models offline and have decomposed the simulated changes into a contribution caused by the variations in temperature and salinity. They concluded that under a warming scenario, and for most models, the weakening of the AMOC is fundamentally driven by temperature anomalies, while freshwater forcing actually acts to stabilise it. However, given that both 3-D fields of ocean temperature and salinity are expected to respond to a forcing at the ocean surface, it is unclear to what extent the diagnostic is informative about the nature of the forcing. To clarify this question, we used the Earth system Model of Intermediate Complexity (EMIC), cGENIE, which is equipped with the C-GOLDSTEIN friction-geostrophic model. First, we reproduced the experiments simulating the Representative Concentration Pathway 8.5 (RCP8.5) warming scenario and observed that cGENIE behaves similarly to the majority of the CMIP5 models considered by Levang and Schmitt (2020) , with the response dominated by the changes in the thermal structure of the ocean. Next, we considered hysteresis experiments associated with (1) water hosing and (2) CO 2 increase and decrease. In all experiments, initial changes in the ocean streamfunction appear to be primarily caused by the changes in the temperature distribution, with variations in the 3-D distribution of salinity only partly compensating for the temperature contribution. These experiments also reveal limited sensitivity to changes in the ocean's salinity inventory. That the diagnostics behave similarly in CO 2 and freshwater forcing scenarios suggests that the output of the diagnostic proposed in Levang and Schmitt (2020) is mainly determined by the internal structure of the ocean circulation rather than by the forcing applied to it. Our results illustrate the difficulty of inferring any information about the applied forcing from the thermal wind diagnostic and raise questions about the feasibility of designing a diagnostic or experiment that could identify which aspect of the forcing (thermal or haline) is driving the weakening of the AMOC.

A new indicator for the AMOC strength still gives no indication of an imminent collapse

New Physics-Based Early Warning Signal shows AMOC is on Tipping Course

Physics-based early warning signal shows that AMOC is on tipping course

Probability Estimates of a 21st Century AMOC Collapse

Deep ocean early warning signals of an Atlantic MOC collapse

Warning of a forthcoming collapse of the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation

Feedback Processes causing an AMOC Collapse in the Community Earth System Model

Why the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation may not collapse

Quantifying risk of a noise-induced AMOC collapse from northern and tropical Atlantic Ocean variability

A pause in the weakening of the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation since the early 2010s

Asymmetry of AMOC Hysteresis in a State-of-the-Art Global Climate Model

Comparing observed and modelled components of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation at 26° N

Diagnosing the causes of AMOC slowdown in a coupled model: a cautionary tale

Dynamical stability indicator based on autoregressive moving-average models: Critical transitions and the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation

Substantial Risk of 21st Century AMOC Tipping even under Moderate Climate Change

Understanding AMOC stability: the North Atlantic Hosing Model Intercomparison Project

Simulating AMOC tipping driven by internal climate variability with a rare event algorithm

Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation Reconstructions and Instrumentally Observed Multidecadal Climate Variability: A Comparison of Indicators

Prediction of slowdown of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation in coupled model simulations

Persistent climate model biases in the Atlantic Ocean's freshwater transport

Optimal Transition Paths for AMOC Collapse and Recovery in a Stochastic Box Model