From giant clumps to clouds IV: extreme star-forming clumps on top of universal cloud scaling relations in gas-rich galaxies

Florent Renaud,Oscar Agertz,Alessandro B. Romeo

2024-02-24

Abstract:The clumpy nature of gas-rich galaxies at cosmic noon raises the question of universality of the scaling relations and average properties of the star-forming structures. Using controlled simulations of disk galaxies and varying only the gas fraction, we show that the influence of the galactic environments (large-scale turbulence, tides, shear) contributes, together with the different regime of instabilities, to setting a diversity of physical conditions for the formation and evolution of gas clumps from low to high gas fractions. However, the distributions of gas clumps at all gas fractions follow similar scaling relations as Larson's, suggesting the universality of median properties. Yet, we find that the scatter around these relations significantly increases with the gas fraction, allowing for the presence of massive, large, and highly turbulent clouds in gas-rich disks in addition to a more classical population of clouds. Clumps with an excess of mass for their size are slightly denser, more centrally concentrated, and host more abundant and faster star formation. We find that the star formation activity (rate, efficiency, depletion time) correlates much more strongly with the excess of mass than with the mass itself. Our results suggest the existence of universal scaling relations for gas clumps but with redshift-dependent scatters, which calls for deeper and more complete census of the populations of star-forming clumps and young stellar clusters at cosmic noon and beyond.

Astrophysics of Galaxies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the properties of star - forming clumps in gas - rich galaxies follow a universal scaling relationship during the cosmic noon period (i.e., the period when the cosmic galaxy - forming activity is the most active, approximately at redshift \(z\approx1 - 3\)), or show different characteristics due to extreme physical conditions. Specifically, by controlling the gas fraction of simulated disk - shaped galaxies, the researchers explored the formation and evolution processes of star - forming clumps under different gas fractions, and how the physical conditions of these clumps are affected by the galactic environment (such as large - scale turbulence, tidal forces, and shear forces).

### Main research questions:
1. **Universality problem**: Do star - forming clumps under different gas fractions follow the same scaling relationships? Are these relationships universal?
2. **Environmental impact**: What is the impact of the galactic environment (such as large - scale turbulence, tidal forces, and shear forces) on the formation and evolution of star - forming clumps?
3. **Clump properties**: What are the differences in mass, size, density, etc. between clumps with a high gas fraction and those with a low gas fraction?
4. **Star - forming activity**: What is the relationship between the mass excess of clumps (relative to their size) and star - forming activities (such as star - formation rate, efficiency, depletion time)?

### Research methods:
- **Simulation experiment**: Use the RAMSES code to simulate a galaxy with an initial mass of \(7\times10^{11}M_{\odot}\), and generate three models (F10, F25, F40) by changing the gas fraction, corresponding to gas fractions of 10%, 25%, and 40% respectively.
- **Clump detection**: Identify gas clumps through over - dense regions in the surface density map, and determine their size and location.
- **Statistical analysis**: Use robust statistical methods (such as median, median absolute deviation, etc.) to analyze the properties of clumps to reduce the influence of outliers.

### Key findings:
- **Universality of scaling relationships**: Although the clump distributions under different gas fractions follow similar scaling relationships, as the gas fraction increases, the dispersion of these relationships increases significantly, allowing for the existence of larger, heavier, and highly turbulent clouds.
- **Environmental impact**: In galaxies with a high gas fraction, turbulence, tidal forces, and shear forces are stronger, which may lead to a shorter lifespan of clumps.
- **Clump properties**: Clumps with a high gas fraction are not only more massive but also have a higher density, are more centrally concentrated, and have more frequent star - forming activities.
- **Star - forming activity**: Star - forming activities (such as star - formation rate, efficiency, depletion time) are more strongly correlated with the mass excess of clumps (relative to their size) rather than simply with the mass of clumps.

### Conclusion:
This study supports the hypothesis that the scaling relationships of star - forming clumps under different gas fractions are universal, but the dispersion of these relationships increases as the gas fraction increases. This indicates that under extreme physical conditions, there may be more large - scale, high - mass, and highly turbulent clumps in galaxies with a high gas fraction. These findings are of great significance for understanding the star - formation process of galaxies during the cosmic noon period.