Abstract:We carry out an extensive comparison between Johnson–Mehl–Avrami–Kolmogorov (JMAK) theory of first-order phase transformation kinetics and phase-field (PF) results of a benchmark problem on nucleation. To address the stochasticity of the problem, several hundreds of simulations are performed to establish a comprehensive, statistically significant analysis of the coincidences and discrepancies between PF and JMAK transformation kinetics. We find that PF predictions are in excellent agreement with both classical nucleation theory and JMAK theory, as long as the original assumptions of the latter are appropriately reproduced—in particular, the constant nucleation and growth rates in an infinite domain. When deviating from these assumptions, PF results are at odds with JMAK theory. In particular, we observe that the size of the initial particle radius r0documentclass[12pt]{minimal}usepackage{amsmath}usepackage{wasysym}usepackage{amsfonts}usepackage{amssymb}usepackage{amsbsy}usepackage{mathrsfs}usepackage{upgreek}setlength{oddsidemargin}{-69pt}egin{document}$$r_0$$end{document} relative to the critical nucleation radius r∗documentclass[12pt]{minimal}usepackage{amsmath}usepackage{wasysym}usepackage{amsfonts}usepackage{amssymb}usepackage{amsbsy}usepackage{mathrsfs}usepackage{upgreek}setlength{oddsidemargin}{-69pt}egin{document}$$r^*$$end{document} has a significant effect on the rate of transformation. While PF and JMAK agree when r0documentclass[12pt]{minimal}usepackage{amsmath}usepackage{wasysym}usepackage{amsfonts}usepackage{amssymb}usepackage{amsbsy}usepackage{mathrsfs}usepackage{upgreek}setlength{oddsidemargin}{-69pt}egin{document}$$r_0$$end{document} is sufficiently higher than r∗documentclass[12pt]{minimal}usepackage{amsmath}usepackage{wasysym}usepackage{amsfonts}usepackage{amssymb}usepackage{amsbsy}usepackage{mathrsfs}usepackage{upgreek}setlength{oddsidemargin}{-69pt}egin{document}$$r^*$$end{document}, the duration of initial transient growth stage of a particle, before it reaches a steady growth velocity, increases as r0/r∗→1documentclass[12pt]{minimal}usepackage{amsmath}usepackage{wasysym}usepackage{amsfonts}usepackage{amssymb}usepackage{amsbsy}usepackage{mathrsfs}usepackage{upgreek}setlength{oddsidemargin}{-69pt}egin{document}$$r_0/r^* ightarrow 1$$end{document}. This incubation time has a significant effect on the overall kinetics, e.g., on the Avrami exponent of the multi-particle simulations. In contrast, for the considered conditions and parameters, the effect of interface curvature upon transformation kinetics—in particular negative curvature regions appearing during particle impingement, present in PF but absent in JMAK theory—appears to be minor compared to that of r0/r∗documentclass[12pt]{minimal}usepackage{amsmath}usepackage{wasysym}usepackage{amsfonts}usepackage{amssymb}usepackage{amsbsy}usepackage{mathrsfs}usepackage{upgreek}setlength{oddsidemargin}{-69pt}egin{document}$$r_0/r^*$$end{document}. We argue that rigorous benchmarking of phase-field models of stochastic processes (e.g., nucleation) needs sufficient statistical data in order to make rigorous comparisons against ground truth theories. In these problems, analysis of probability distributions is clearly preferable to a deterministic approach.

Friction and Memory Effects in Homogeneous Gas-Liquid Nucleation: Quest for Quantitative Rate Calculation

Alternative Theory of Nucleation in Super-Cooled Liquids

Non-Markovian Effects in Quantum Rate Calculations of Hydrogen Diffusion with Electronic Friction

Memory Effects Explain the Fractional Viscosity Dependence of Rates associated with Internal Friction: Simple Models and Applications to Butane Dihedral Rotation

Igniting homogeneous nucleation

Homogeneous Nucleation in a Laminar Flow Diffusion Chamber: the Operation Principles and Possibilities for Quantitative Rate Measurements

Unraveling the "Pressure-Effect" in Nucleation

Memory and Friction: From the Nanoscale to the Macroscale

Classical theory of nucleation applied to condensation of a Lennard-Jones fluid

Atomistic Investigation of Homogeneous Nucleation in Undercooled Liquid

Prediction of the Homogeneous Nucleation Rate by Fluctuation Theory

Pressure in the Landau-Ginzburg Functional: Pascal's Law, Nucleation in Fluid Mixtures, a Meanfield Theory of Amphiphilic Action, and Interface Wetting in Glassy Liquids

Theory of a quantum-mechanical nucleation rate: classical vs. quantal nucleation

Characterization of Condensation on Nanostructured Surfaces and Associated Thermal Hydraulics Using a Thermal Lattice Boltzmann Method.

Persistent Thermal Inhomogeneities in a Gas-Cluster Mixture

Heterogeneous Nucleation of Vapor on Insoluble Particles Predicted by an Improved Classical Nucleation Theory

Re-Evaluation Of The Pressure Effect For Nucleation In Laminar Flow Diffusion Chamber Experiments With Fluent And The Fine Particle Model

The Influence of Particle Solubility on Heterogeneous Nucleation in Binary Vapor Mixtures

On the Effect of Nucleation Undercooling on Phase Transformation Kinetics

Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Heterogeneous Nucleation of Argon Vapor Onto a Spherical Solid Particle

Homogeneous Nucleation Of N-Nonane And N-Propanol Mixtures: A Comparison Of Classical Nucleation Theory And Experiments