The Dual Dynamical Foundation of Orthodox Quantum Mechanics

Diana Taschetto,Ricardo Correa da Silva
2024-02-23
Abstract:This paper combines mathematical, philosophical, and historical analyses in a comprehensive investigation of the dynamical foundations of the formalism of orthodox quantum mechanics. The results obtained include: (i) A deduction of the canonical commutation relations (CCR) from the tenets of Matrix Mechanics; (ii) A discussion of the meaning of Schrödinger's first derivation of the wave equation that not only improves on Joas and Lehner's 2009 investigation on the subject but also demonstrates that the CCR follow of necessity from Schrödinger's first derivation of the wave equation, thus correcting the common misconception that the CCR were only posited by Schrödinger to pursue equivalence with Matrix Mechanics; (iii) A discussion of the mathematical facts and requirements involved in the equivalence of Matrix and Wave Mechanics that improves on F. A. Muller's classical treatment of the subject; (iv) A proof that the equivalence of Matrix and Wave Mechanics is necessitated by the formal requirements of a dual action functional from which both the dynamical postulates of orthodox quantum mechanics, von Neumann's process 1 and process 2, follow; (v) A critical assessment, based on (iii) and (iv), of von Neumann's construction of unified quantum mechanics over Hilbert space. Point (iv) is our main result. It brings to the open the important, but hitherto ignored, fact that orthodox quantum mechanics is no exception to the golden rule of physics that the dynamics of a physical theory must follow from the action functional. If orthodox quantum mechanics, based as it is on the assumption of the equivalence of Matrix and Wave Mechanics, has this "peculiar dual dynamics," as von Neumann called it, this is so because by assuming the equivalence one has been assuming a peculiar dual action.
History and Philosophy of Physics,Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the dynamical basis of the formalism of quantum mechanics. Specifically: 1. **Derivation of the Canonical Commutation Relations**: The paper attempts to derive the Canonical Commutation Relations (CCR), i.e., \( [q, p] = i\hbar \), from the basic principles of matrix mechanics. This is not only a supplement to historical literature but also a deepening of the existing understanding, especially correcting the common misunderstanding that Schrödinger assumed CCR only for the purpose of being equivalent to matrix mechanics when he first derived the wave equation. 2. **The Equivalence of Matrix Mechanics and Wave Mechanics**: The paper discusses in detail the mathematical facts and requirements of the equivalence between matrix mechanics and wave mechanics and improves the classical treatment method of F. A. Muller in this field. The author proves that this equivalence is determined by the formal requirements of a double - action functional, thus revealing the origin of the dynamical duality in orthodox quantum mechanics. 3. **The Dynamical Basis of Orthodox Quantum Mechanics**: The core result of the paper is the discovery of a double - action functional, from which all the dynamical postulates of orthodox quantum mechanics, including von Neumann's Process 1 and Process 2, can be necessarily derived. This finding indicates that orthodox quantum mechanics is not an exception, and its dynamics must also follow the golden rule in physical theories - that is, the dynamics must be derived from the action functional. 4. **Von Neumann's Unified Quantum Mechanics**: Based on the above findings, the paper makes a critical evaluation of von Neumann's unified quantum mechanics constructed in Hilbert space. The author believes that von Neumann's formulation of the measurement problem does not conform to the official understanding, that is, the so - called "problem of outcomes". By solving this problem, the paper clarifies some misunderstandings of von Neumann's argument, especially refuting the contemporary accusations against von Neumann's dignity as a mathematician, such as "casual", "arbitrary" and "stupid" as John Bell called. In conclusion, through a combination of mathematical, philosophical and historical analysis, this paper comprehensively explores the dynamical basis of orthodox quantum mechanics, especially the profound insights into the equivalence between matrix mechanics and wave mechanics, and the mathematical basis of the double - action functional behind these equivalences.