Social Environment Design

Edwin Zhang,Sadie Zhao,Tonghan Wang,Safwan Hossain,Henry Gasztowtt,Stephan Zheng,David C. Parkes,Milind Tambe,Yiling Chen

2024-06-18

Abstract:Artificial Intelligence (AI) holds promise as a technology that can be used to improve government and economic policy-making. This paper proposes a new research agenda towards this end by introducing Social Environment Design, a general framework for the use of AI for automated policy-making that connects with the Reinforcement Learning, EconCS, and Computational Social Choice communities. The framework seeks to capture general economic environments, includes voting on policy objectives, and gives a direction for the systematic analysis of government and economic policy through AI simulation. We highlight key open problems for future research in AI-based policy-making. By solving these challenges, we hope to achieve various social welfare objectives, thereby promoting more ethical and responsible decision making.

Artificial Intelligence,General Economics,Machine Learning

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem addressed in this paper is how to better utilize artificial intelligence (AI) for policy making to address the complexity and fairness issues in economic policy making, as well as the potential conflicts of interest among policy makers. The paper proposes a new research agenda called "social environment design," which is a framework that combines AI with reinforcement learning, computational economics, and social choice theory for automated policy making. The framework aims to capture the general economic environment, including voting on policy objectives, and systematically analyze government and economic policies through AI simulation.

Key points include:
1. Ensuring alignment of policy makers' values with those of the voters to ensure fairness and representative participation.
2. The model needs to have sufficient expressive power to accurately reflect the complex governance structures in the real world.
3. While maintaining expressive power, computational feasibility should also be guaranteed to scale to systems with a large number of agents.
4. Developing theoretical understanding and systematically analyzing complex economic models through AI simulation.

The paper introduces several key questions for future research and hopes to achieve various social welfare goals and promote more ethical and responsible decision-making through addressing these challenges. It also presents a specific game framework, the Apple Harvesting Game, as an example to illustrate how AI-guided policy design can balance individual and collective interests, as well as address issues of preference aggregation and democratic representation. Finally, the paper outlines the challenges faced in AI-driven economic policy making, such as preference aggregation, human behavior modeling, AI governance and accountability, convergence to desired outcomes, and other open questions.