Fractal scaling and the aesthetics of trees

Jingyi Gao,Mitchell Newberry

2024-02-21

Abstract:Trees in works of art have stirred emotions in viewers for millennia. Leonardo da Vinci described geometric proportions in trees to provide both guidelines for painting and insights into tree form and function. Da Vinci's Rule of trees further implies fractal branching with a particular scaling exponent $\alpha = 2$ governing both proportions between the diameters of adjoining boughs and the number of boughs of a given diameter. Contemporary biology increasingly supports an analogous rule with $\alpha = 3$ known as Murray's Law. Here we relate trees in art to a theory of proportion inspired by both da Vinci and modern tree physiology. We measure $\alpha$ in 16th century Islamic architecture, Edo period Japanese painting and 20th century European art, finding $\alpha$ in the range 1.5 to 2.5. We find that both conformity and deviations from ideal branching create stylistic effect and accommodate constraints on design and implementation. Finally, we analyze an abstract tree by Piet Mondrian which forgoes explicit branching but accurately captures the modern scaling exponent $\alpha = 3$, anticipating Murray's Law by 15 years. This perspective extends classical mathematical, biological and artistic ways to understand, recreate and appreciate the beauty of trees.

Physics and Society,Popular Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of exploring the relationship between the proportions of trees in artworks and the physiology of real trees, and to verify these relationships by measuring the proportions of trees in different artworks. The paper mainly focuses on how the proportions of trees in artworks reflect or deviate from the idealized fractal branching pattern and analyzes the impact of these proportions on artistic style.

Specifically, the paper attempts to answer the following questions:
1. **Proportions of trees in artworks**: Do the proportions of trees in artworks conform to Leonardo's rule (i.e., a specific fractal branching ratio)? If not, how do these deviations occur?
2. **Relationship between proportions and artistic style**: How do the proportions of trees in artworks from different cultures and periods affect visual effects and artistic styles?
3. **Application of modern biological theories**: Can the proportions of trees in artworks reflect modern biological theories, such as Murray's Law, which describes the proportional relationships in vascular systems?
4. **Representation of trees in abstract art**: Even in the absence of explicit branches, can abstract artworks (such as Mondrian's works) capture the proportional characteristics of trees?

By measuring representative artworks from different historical periods, the paper reveals the different ways of handling tree proportions in artistic creation and the scientific basis behind them.